1 Corinthians 10:10 . Nor murmur , etc.; expression of contumacious discontent ( Matthew 20:11 ; Php 2:14 ), without right or reason. Against whom ? is discovered from the narrative , to which Paul here refers us. That this is to be found not in Numbers 14 (the more common view),...
Show full excerpt
1 Corinthians 10:10 . Nor murmur , etc.; expression of contumacious discontent ( Matthew 20:11 ; Php 2:14 ), without right or reason. Against whom ? is discovered from the narrative , to which Paul here refers us. That this is to be found not in Numbers 14 (the more common view), but in Numbers 16:41 ; Numbers 16:49 (Calvin, de Wette, Osiander, Neander, Maier, Ewald), is clear, in the first place, because ἀπώλλ . ὑπὸ τ . ὀλοθρ . denotes a violent death, which does not tally with Numbers 14; and, in the second, because τινὲς αὐτῶν cannot apply to the whole people (except Caleb and Joshua), which it would have to do according to Numbers 14. If, however, what Paul has here in view is the murmuring against Moses and Aaron after the death of Korah and his company ( Numbers 16:41 ; Numbers 16:49 ), then his prohibition must refer not to discontent against God (which was, moreover, referred to already in 1 Corinthians 10:9 ), but only to murmuring against the divinely commissioned teachers (Paul, Apollos, and others), who, in their position and authoritative exercise of discipline, corresponded to the type of Moses and Aaron as the theocratic leaders and teachers of the rebellious people. And it is for this reason that he uses the second person here, although the first both precedes and follows it.