Joshua 4:9

Joshua 4:9

Commentary from the Reformed tradition and beyond

How we matched these sections:
PinpointedTouchesSemantically Found
MacLaren's Expositions — MacLaren's Expositions — Joshua (BibleHub)
Pinpointed
Joshua STONES CRYING OUTJoshua 4:10 - Joshua 4:24 . This chapter is divided into two sections. The first {from Joshua 4:1 - Joshua 4:14 } has as its main subject the bringing up of the twelve memorial stones from the bed of Jordan; the second { Joshua 4:15 - Joshua 4:24 } gives t...
Show full excerpt
Joshua STONES CRYING OUTJoshua 4:10 - Joshua 4:24 . This chapter is divided into two sections. The first {from Joshua 4:1 - Joshua 4:14 } has as its main subject the bringing up of the twelve memorial stones from the bed of Jordan; the second { Joshua 4:15 - Joshua 4:24 } gives the conclusion of the whole incident. The plan of arrangement, already pointed out in a former chapter, is very plain in this. Each section has God’s commands to Joshua, Joshua’s to the people, and the execution of these. To each is appended a summary, which anticipates the more detailed particulars that follow. Our text begins in the middle of the first section, but we must glance at the preceding verses. These tell how, when the people were all across, Joshua, who had apparently remained on the eastern bank with the twelve representatives of the tribes, received God’s command to tell these the purpose for which they had been chosen, and to set them to execute it. This additional instruction is the explanation of the apparent discrepancy between Joshua 3:12 and Joshua 4:2 .
MacLaren's Expositions — MacLaren's Expositions — Joshua (BibleHub)
Pinpointed
Joshua 4:4 - Joshua 4:8 tell Joshua’s communication of the instructions to the men; Joshua 4:8 narrates the execution of them by each man’s wrenching up from the river’s bed a great stone, with which he toiled through the muddy ooze to the western shore, and thence over the hot p...
Show full excerpt
Joshua 4:4 - Joshua 4:8 tell Joshua’s communication of the instructions to the men; Joshua 4:8 narrates the execution of them by each man’s wrenching up from the river’s bed a great stone, with which he toiled through the muddy ooze to the western shore, and thence over the hot plain to Gilgal, where the host camped; Joshua 4:9 tells that twelve other stones were set up where the priests had stood, and were visible at some time after date, when it was written; but when that was, or whether the verse is part of the original or a later note, we cannot say. At any rate, there were two memorials, one on the bank, one in the stream-’a grand jury of great stones,’ as Thomas Fuller calls them. There is no difficulty in supposing that the monument in the river was firm enough to resist its current, and high enough to be visible either above the surface or beneath the ordinarily shallow water. I. The first picture here brought before us is that of the motionless ark in the midst of what had been Jordan. There is an obvious intention to contrast the stillness of the priests, bearing it on their shoulders, and standing rooted in that strange place all these long hours, with the hurry around. ‘The priests stood . . . and the people hasted.’ However broad the front and swift the march, the crossing must have taken many hours. The haste was not from fear, but eagerness.
Benson Commentary — Benson Commentary — Joshua (BibleHub)
Pinpointed
Joshua 4:9 . Joshua set up twelve stones in the midst of Jordan — These stones are not the same with those mentioned Joshua 4:5 , which a man might carry upon his shoulder. They were undoubtedly very much larger, and probably appeared above the surface of the water, when it was l...
Show full excerpt
Joshua 4:9 . Joshua set up twelve stones in the midst of Jordan — These stones are not the same with those mentioned Joshua 4:5 , which a man might carry upon his shoulder. They were undoubtedly very much larger, and probably appeared above the surface of the water, when it was low; or, if not, might be seen in it, either from the shore, the river not being broad, or in crossing it by boats, the waters of Jordan being generally very clear. At least they were so placed as to show that they were some monument of art, and erected there when the channel of the river was dry. They are there unto this day — That is, unto the time when this history was written, which might not be till many years after the facts were done, recorded in it. Or, it might be added by Joshua himself in his old age, or by some other holy and divinely-inspired man, who inserted this and some such passages, both in this book and in the writings of Moses.
Cambridge Bible for Schools and Colleges — Cambridge Bible for Schools and Colleges — Joshua (BibleHub)
Pinpointed
9 . And Joshua set up twelve stones in the midst of Jordan ] “Alios quoque duodecim lapides,” Vulg. Another set of stones is here intended than that just mentioned. The latter were set up by the direct command of God to mark the spot where they passed the night; the former Joshua...
Show full excerpt
9 . And Joshua set up twelve stones in the midst of Jordan ] “Alios quoque duodecim lapides,” Vulg. Another set of stones is here intended than that just mentioned. The latter were set up by the direct command of God to mark the spot where they passed the night; the former Joshua set up, apparently without the Divine suggestion, to mark the spot where the feet of the priests rested, while they bare upwards the Ark during the passage of the people. The expression “midst of Jordan” does not necessarily imply that the priests stood, and that the stones were built up, in the middle channel; but only that they were in the midst of the water when it flowed as it did before the occurrence of the miracle. Comp. Joshua 3:8 with Joshua 3:15 . unto this day ] This phrase recurs again and again in the Book of Joshua. Comp. Joshua 5:9 ; Joshua 6:25 ; Joshua 7:26 ; Joshua 8:28-29 ; Joshua 9:27 ; Joshua 10:27 ; Joshua 13:13 ; Joshua 14:14 ; Joshua 15:63 ; Joshua 16:10 .

Commentary excerpts drawn from the Waymark library. Explore the full texts for deeper context.

© 2026 Waymark