Genesis 17:18

Genesis 17:18

Commentary from the Reformed tradition and beyond

How we matched these sections:
PinpointedTouchesSemantically Found
MacLaren's Expositions — MacLaren's Expositions — Genesis (BibleHub)
Pinpointed
Genesis A PETULANT WISHGenesis 17:18 . These words sound very devout, and they have often been used by Christian parents yearning for the best interests of their children, and sometimes of their wayward and prodigal children. But consecrated as they are by that usage, I am afraid...
Show full excerpt
Genesis A PETULANT WISHGenesis 17:18 . These words sound very devout, and they have often been used by Christian parents yearning for the best interests of their children, and sometimes of their wayward and prodigal children. But consecrated as they are by that usage, I am afraid that their meaning, as they were uttered, was nothing so devout and good as that which is often attached to them. 1. Note the temper in which Abraham speaks here. The very existence of Ishmael was a memorial of Abraham’s failure in faith and patience. For he thought that the promised heir was long in coming, and so he thought that he would help God. For thirteen years the child had been living beside him, winding a son’s way into a father’s heart, with much in his character, as was afterwards seen, that would make a frank, daring boy his old father’s darling. Then all at once comes the divine message, ‘This is not the son of the Covenant; this is not the heir of the Promise. Sarah shall have a child, and from him shall come the blessings that have been foretold.’ And what does Abraham do? Fall down in thankfulness before God? leap up in heart at the conviction that now at last the long-looked-for fulfilment of the oath of God was impending? Not he. ‘O that Ishmael might live before Thee. Why cannot he do? Why may he not be the chosen child, the heir of the Promise? Take him, O God!’ That is to say, he thinks he knows better than God.
MacLaren's Expositions — MacLaren's Expositions — Genesis (BibleHub)
Pinpointed
He is petulant, he resists his blessing, he fancies that his own plan is quite as good as the divine plan. He does not want to draw away his heart from the child that it has twined round. So he loses the blessing of the revelation that is being made to him; because he does not bo...
Show full excerpt
He is petulant, he resists his blessing, he fancies that his own plan is quite as good as the divine plan. He does not want to draw away his heart from the child that it has twined round. So he loses the blessing of the revelation that is being made to him; because he does not bow his will, and accept God’s way instead of his own. Now, do you not think that that is what we do? When God sends us Isaac, do we not often say, ‘Take Ishmael; he is my own making. I have set all my hopes on him. Why should I have to wrench them all away?’ In our individual lives we want to prescribe to God, far too often, not only the ends , but the way in which we shall get to the ends; and we think to ourselves, ‘That road of my own engineering that I have got all staked out, that is the true way for God’s providence to take.’ And when His path does not coincide with ours, then we are discontented, and instead of submitting we go with our pet schemes to Him; and if not in so many words, at least in spirit and temper, we try to force our way upon God, and when He is speaking about Isaac insist on pressing Ishmael on His notice. It is often so in regard to our individual lives; and it is so in regard to the united action of Christian people very often.
Benson Commentary — Benson Commentary — Genesis (BibleHub)
Pinpointed
Genesis 17:18 . And Abraham said, O that Ishmael might live before thee! — This he speaks, not as desiring that Ishmael might be preferred before the son he should have by Sarah, but as dreading lest he should be forsaken of God. The great thing we should desire of God for our ch...
Show full excerpt
Genesis 17:18 . And Abraham said, O that Ishmael might live before thee! — This he speaks, not as desiring that Ishmael might be preferred before the son he should have by Sarah, but as dreading lest he should be forsaken of God. The great thing we should desire of God for our children is, that they may live before him; that is, that they may be kept in covenant with him, and may have grace to walk before him in uprightness. God’s answer to this prayer is an answer of peace. Abraham could not say he sought God’s face in vain; nor shall we, if we seek it sincerely.
Ellicott's Commentary for English Readers — Ellicott's Commentary for English Readers — Genesis (BibleHub)
Pinpointed
(18) O that Ishmael . . . — For thirteen years Ishmael had been the “son of the house” ( Genesis 15:3 ), and regarded probably as the true heir. Mingled then with Abraham’s joy there was also the pain, natural to a father, of knowing that this transference of the promise to Sarah...
Show full excerpt
(18) O that Ishmael . . . — For thirteen years Ishmael had been the “son of the house” ( Genesis 15:3 ), and regarded probably as the true heir. Mingled then with Abraham’s joy there was also the pain, natural to a father, of knowing that this transference of the promise to Sarah’s child meant the deposition and disappointment of one who for so long had held the post of honour. Stoicism would have repressed this upright and natural feeling, but God hears and accepts the father’s prayers; and while the birthright and religious pre-eminence is justly given to the son of the freewoman, there is a large earthly blessing for the handmaid’s son.
Cambridge Bible for Schools and Colleges — Cambridge Bible for Schools and Colleges — Genesis (BibleHub)
Pinpointed
18 . said unto God ] The previous verse contained what Abraham “said in his heart.” Aloud he expresses his incredulity in a more reverent manner, shewing that his hope of descendants rested upon Ishmael. might live before thee ] i.e. that his life might be blessed by God’s specia...
Show full excerpt
18 . said unto God ] The previous verse contained what Abraham “said in his heart.” Aloud he expresses his incredulity in a more reverent manner, shewing that his hope of descendants rested upon Ishmael. might live before thee ] i.e. that his life might be blessed by God’s special protection.
Geneva Study Bible — Geneva Study Bible — Genesis (BibleHub)
Pinpointed
And Abraham said unto God, O that Ishmael might live before thee!

Commentary excerpts drawn from the Waymark library. Explore the full texts for deeper context.

© 2026 Waymark