William Cunningham · Historical Theology: A Review of the Principal Doctrinal Discussions in the Christian Church Since the Apostolic Age, Vol. 2
Historical Theology: A Review of the Principal Doctrinal Discussions in the Christian Church Since the Apostolic Age, Vol. 2
by William Cunningham
About this work
Year
1863
Text preparation
Linguistically cleaned with LLM assistance. 3888 applied changes.
Applied changes (3888)
-
JusTIFICATION → JUSTIFICATION
OCR small-caps misread; chapter heading should read JUSTIFICATION
-
SAcRAMENTAL → SACRAMENTAL
Chaotic OCR case; heading uses small caps rendered as SACRAMENTAL
-
HAPTER → CHAPTER
OCR dropped initial C; heading reads CHAPTER XXIII
-
DoctRIne → Doctrine
chaotic OCR casing; heading reads 'Doctrine of the Atonement' like other headings
-
TxHE → THE
OCR capitalization garble of THE in chapter heading
-
; → ;
remove spurious space before punctuation
-
distinguish- ing → distinguishing
join hyphenated line break
-
; → ;
Remove stray space before semicolon
-
cur- sory → cursory
hyphenated line break of 'cursory' joined once
-
. t → . t
sentence-ending period followed by line break before 'that'; retain period and continuation
-
controver- sial → controversial
join hyphenated line break
-
controver- sies → controversies
join hyphenated line break
-
cen- tury → century
hyphenated line break joining 'cen-' + 'tury'
-
Re- formers → Reformers
hyphenated line break joining 'Re-' and 'formers' into the complete word
-
indivi- dually → individually
hyphenated line break joining 'indivi-' and 'dually'
-
sub- ject → subject
hyphenated line break splitting 'subject'; join complete token
-
mon- strous → monstrous
hyphenated_line_break joining split token
-
; → ;
remove spurious space before semicolon
-
; → ;
stray spacing around semicolon; insert space before punctuation
-
follow- ing → following
Join hyphenated line break into 'following'
-
sub- jects → subjects
hyphenated line break splitting 'subjects'; join complete token once
-
re- generated → regenerated
hyphenated line break; join split token
-
pro- per → proper
hyphenated line break; join split token
-
; → ;
remove stray space before semicolon
-
cor- rectness → correctness
hyphenated line break joins to 'correctness'
Showing 25 of 3888.
SS oN Seay
“va
en Sook ae Spee pei Sees
Oe a oe
” ‘wk
G aa tr ’ ; lt ; € +f J
sine a isi iy
+ % .
ba i Pactra fi ; i" ‘P 4) he ie
ty? , ,
bia ts } \ i . 3 aa Wi 9 Te ‘ A Phatth
Digitized by the Internet Archive in 2023 with funding from Kahle/Austin Foundation
https://archive.org/details/gtu_A32400003855388B _2
ISTORIGAL THEOLOGY
A REVIEW OF THE PRINCIPAL DOCTRINAL DISCUSSIONS
IN THE CHRISTIAN CHURCH SINCE
THE APOSTOLIC AGE.
BY THE LATE
WILLIAM CUNNINGHAM, D.D.,
PRINCIPAL AND PROFESSOR OF CHURCH HISTORY, NEW COLLEGE, EDINBURGH.
EDITED BY HIS LITERARY EXECUTORS.
Property of Vi Te Te. SK Please return to Grad -° theological
EDINBURGH:
T. AND T. CLARK, 38, GEORGE STREET.
LONDON: HAMILTON, ADAMS, & CO. DUBLIN: JOHN ROBERTSON.
MDCCCLAIII.
s 3 (% 4 i34 * “-
MURRAY AND GIBB, PRINTERS, EDINBURGH.
CONTENTS.
—_—___¢—_—_———_-
aa Page
CHAPTER XXI.—JusTIFICATION, . : : : : : : il
Sec. 1. Popish and Protestant Views, : : : ; : 10 » 2. Nature of Justification, é : : : : 31 ,, 3. Imputation of Christ’s Peotiteaueoeat ’ ; : ; 45 ,» 4. Justification by Faith alone, : : : : : 56 , 5. Office of Faith in Justifying, : - ? : é 68 ,, 6. Objections to the Scriptural Doctrine, . : : ‘ 79 », 7. The Forgiveness of Post- baptismal Sins, 3 : j 90 »> 8- The Merit of Good Works, . 101 ,» 9- Practical Tendency of the Popish Tocine of J Se rertntel 111
CHAPTER XXII.—TuE SAcRAMENTAL PRINCIPLE, . é : : 121
Src. 1. Sacramental Grace, : : : é : ‘ : 121 ,» 2. Baptismal Regeneration, : é : : 5 133 ,» 3. Popish View of the Lord’s super ; : E ; 142 » 4. Infant Baptism, : : : : : : 144 sy HAPTER XXIII.—Tue SOCINIAN CONTROVERSY, Z ; : 155 Sec. 1. Origin of Socinianism, : : é : : : : 156 , 2. Socinian Views as to Scripture, . : : : ‘ 160 ,, 8. Socinian System of Theology, é : : ; . 168 ,» 4. Original and Recent Socinianism, . : ; ¢ ; 188 ,, 5. Distinction of Persons in the Godhead, . j : é 192 ,, 6. Trinity and Unity, : : 2 ; . 203 ,, 7. Evidence for the Divinity of Christ, ; : . 2 213
CHAPTER XXIV.—DoctRIne OF THE ATONEMENT, F : : 237
. ge. 1. Connection between the Person and Work of Christ, . 237 », 2. Necessity of the Atonement, : : 248 », 3. The Necessity and Nature of the Ateneay : . 260
P4047"
iv CONTENTS.
Page
CHAPTER XXIV.—Continued.
Sec. 4. Objections to the Doctrine of Atonement, . , . 269
», 5. Scriptural Evidence for the Atonement, : 5 : 279 5, 6. Socinian View of the Atonement, _ : 5 3 293 5, 7. Arminian View of the Atonement, : : : 2 300 », 8. Extent of the Atonement, . : ; : ; 322 » 9. Evidence as to the Extent of the Atonamene ; : 335 », 10. Extent of Atonement and Gospel Offer, ; : : 342 », 11. Extent of Atonement, and its Object, . 5 5 847 », 12. Extent of the Atonement, and Calvinistic Panel é 359
CHAPTER XXV.—TxHE ARMINIAN CONTROVERSY, . : - ° 3871.
Sec. 1. Arminius and the Arminians, : : : 2 , 371 +, 2. Synod of Dort, . : . A 2 : é : 379 », 93. The Five Points, . : : : . 5 : 2 384 », 4. Original Sin, : : : : : : 386 », ©. Universal and Effectual Calizes! : : : ; : 394 », 6. Efficacious and Irresistible Grace, : : : : 405 » 7. The Decrees of God, . : * : : é 416 Pied Predestination ene of the Gaeceiod, : : ; 430 », 9. Predestination, and the Doctrine of the Fall, : : 439 ney dO, Peeiesuninuon, and the Omniscience of God, : ; 444 », 11. Predestination, and the Sovereignty of God, : : 449 ,, 12. Scripture Evidence for Predestination, : : . 459 », 138. Objections against Predestination, : : : : 472 », 14. Perseverance of Saints, : ; ; : : 490 ay Albay. Socinianism—Arminianismi——Calyiniam, 5 : : 501
CHAPTER XXVI—Cuurcu GOVERNMENT, . : : ‘ : 514
Sec. 1. Presbyterianism, : ‘ 514 » 2. Testimony of the Retienare a as to Preniyteriawica : 525 ,», 3. Popular Election of Office-bearers, , : C : 534 », 4. Congregationalism, or Indepen dency, : ; : 545
CHAPTER XXVU.—Tue Erastian Controversy, ; : : 557
Sec. 1. The Civil Magistrate and Religion, : é : ; 557 », 2. Erastus and the Erastians, . : : 569 » 93. Erastianism during the Ssventeantn dae : : 576 » 4. The Free Church of Scotland, : : ; : ‘ 583
eS
CHAPTER XXTI.
JUSTIFICATION,
WE now proceed to the consideration of the important subject of Justification ; and it will be proper to enter somewhat more fully ‘into the investigation of this topic than those which we have hitherto examined. This was the great fundamental distinguish- ing doctrine of the Reformation, and was regarded by all the Reformers as of primary and paramount importance. The leading charge which they adduced against the Church of Rome was, that ‘she had corrupted and perverted the doctrine of Scripture upon this subject in a way that was dangerous to the souls of men; and it was mainly by the exposition, ationonene and application of the true doctrine of God’s word in regard to it, that they assailed and overturned the leading doctrines and practices of the Papal “system. There is no subject which possesses more of intrinsic im- ‘portance than attaches to this one, and there is none with respect to which the Reformers were more thoroughly harmonious in their sentiments. All who believe that the truth on this subject ‘had been greatly corrupted in the Church of Rome, and that the doctrine taught by the Reformers respecting it was scriptural and true, must necessarily regard the restoration of sound doctrine ‘upon this point as the most important service which the Reformers “were made instrumental by God in rendering to the church. It is above all things important, that men, if they have broken the law of God, and become liable to the punishment which the aw denounces against transgression,—and that this is, indeed, the
_ 3.—VOL, II. A
b “ 4
4
2 JUSTIFICATION. [Cuar. XXI.
state of men by nature is of course now assumed,—should know whether there be any way in which they may obtain the pardon and deliverance they need; and if so, what that way is. And it is the doctrine of justification as taught in Scripture which alone affords a satisfactory answer to the question. The subject thus bears most directly and immediately upon men’s relation to God and their everlasting destiny, and is fraught with unspeakable practical importance to every human being. It is assumed now that the condition of men by nature is such in point of fact,—that some change or changes must be effected regarding them in order to their escaping fearful evil and enjoying permanent happiness ; and it is in this way that the doctrine of justification is connected with that of original sin, as the nature and constituent elements of the disease must determine the nature and qualities of the remedy that may be fitted to cure or remove it.
There is, indeed, as must be evident even upon the most cur- sory survey of what Scripture teaches concerning the recovery and salvation of lost men, a great subject or class of subjects, that is intermediate between the general state of mankind as fallen and lost, and the deliverance and restoration of men individually. And this is the work of Christ as mediator, and the general place or function assigned to the Holy Spirit in the salvation of sinners. The Scripture represents the whole human race as involved by the fall in a state of sin and misery. It represents God as looking with compassion and love upon the lost race of man, and as devising a method of effecting and'securing their salvation. It describes this divine method of saving sinners as founded on, or rather as_ consisting substantially in, this,—that God sent His Son into the world to assume human nature, and to suffer and die in order to procure or purchase for them salvation, and everything which salvation might involve or require. And hence, in turning our attention from men’s actual condition of sin and misery to the remedy which has been provided, the first great subject which naturally presents itself to our contemplation and study is the person and the work of the Mediator, or the investigation of these three questions,—viz., first, Who and what was this Saviour of sinners whom the Scriptures set before us? secondly, What is it. that He has done in order to save men from ruin, and to restore them to happiness? and, thirdly, In what way is it that His work, or what He did and suffered, bears upon the accomplishment of
PONE ANS
xe
: Cuar. XXI.J JUSTIFICATION. 3
the great object which it was designed to effect? Now, the first _ two of these subjects.,—i.e., the person and the work of Christ, or His divinity and atonement,—did not form subjects of controver- sial discussion between the Reformers and the Romanists. The Church of Rome has always held the proper divinity and the vicarious atonement of Christ; and though these great doctrines have been so corrupted and perverted by her as to be in a great measure practically neutralized, and though it is very important to point out this, yet these subjects cannot be said to constitute a point of the proper controversy between the Church of Rome and the Protestants, and they were not in point of fact discussed between the Romanists and the Reformers. In all the controver- sies between them, the divinity and the vicarious atonement of Christ were assumed as topics in which there was no material difference of opinion in formal profession,—doctrines which each party was entitled to take for granted in arguing with the other. The subject, indeed, of the divinity and atonement of our Saviour _ did not occupy much of the attention of any portion of the church, as subjects of controversial discussion, during the sixteenth cen- tury; for the works of Socinus, who first gave to anti-Trinitarian views, and to the denial of a vicarious atonement, a plausible and imposing aspect, did not excite much attention till about the end of this century, and the controversies which they occasioned took _ place chiefly in the succeeding one. I propose, therefore, following the chronological order, to postpone for the present any account of the discussions which have taken place concerning the divinity ~ and atonement of Christ. The sum and substance of the great charge which the Re- formers adduced against the Church of Rome was, that while she _ proclaimed to men with a considerable measure of accuracy who Christ was, and what it was that He had done for the salvation of _-sinners, she yet perverted the gospel of the grace of God, and endangered the salvation of men’s souls, by setting before them erroneous and unscriptural views of the grounds on which, and
- the process through which, the blessings that Christ had procured
for mankind at large were actually bestowed upon men indivi- dually, and of the way and manner in which men individually became possessed of them, and attained ultimately to the full and " permanent enjoyment of them, This was the subject that may be said to have been discussed between the Reformers and the
4 JUSTIFICATION. [Cuar. XXID
Romanists under the head of justification, and I need say nothing more to show its paramount practical importance. There can be no difference of opinion as to the importance of the general sub- ject which has been indicated; but there have been occasionally discussions in more modern times upon the question whether the errors of the Church of Rome upon this subject are so important and dangerous as they are often represented to be, and whether they were of sufficient magnitude to warrant the views entertained by the Reformers upon this subject, and the course of practical procedure which they based upon these views. When more lax and unsound views of doctrine began to prevail in the Protestant churches, some of their divines lost their sense of the magnitude of the Romish errors upon the subject of justification, and began to make admissions, that the differences between them and the Romanists upon this point were not so vital as the Reformers had supposed them to be; and the Romanists, ever on the watch to take advantage of anything that seems fitted to promote the interests of their church, were not slow to avail themselves of these concessions.* There are two different and opposite lines of policy which Romish controversialists have pursued upon this subject, according as seemed to be most expedient for their interests at the time. Sometimes they have represented the doctrine of the Reformers upon the subject of justification as something hideous and mon- strous,—as overturning the foundations of all morality, and fitted only to produce universal wickedness and profligacy ; and at other: times they have affected a willingness to listen to the grounds on which Protestants defend themselves from this charge, to admit that these grounds are not altogether destitute of weight, and that, consequently, there is not so great a difference between their’ doctrine in substance and that of the Church of Rome. They then enlarge upon the important influence which the alleged. errors of the Church of Rome on the subject of justification had.
_* Archbishop Wake, in his Exposi- | churchmen, Perceval, in his ‘“‘ Roman: tion of the Doctrine of the Church of | Schism Illustrated” (p.365), says, that ; England, in reply to Bossuet’s Expo- | ‘‘ ground for condemnation of the: sition of the Catholic Church, gives | Church of Rome, as touching the main: up our whole controversy with the | positions of this doctrine, is not to be! Church of Rome on this subject; and | found in the decrees of the Council of ' to give a specimen of modern High- | Trent.”
Cuap, XXI.] JUSTIFICATION. 5
~ in producing the Reformation,—quote some of the passages which 4 _ show the paramount importance which the first Reformers attached ? to this subject,—and proceed to draw the inference that the Re- _ formation was founded upon misrepresentation and calumny, since it appears, and has been admitted even by learned Protestants, that the errors of the Church of Rome, even if they were to admit for the sake of argument that she had erred, are not nearly so important as the Reformers had represented them to be.* It is only to this second line of policy, which represents the difference on the subject of justification as comparatively insigni- -ficant, and makes use, for this purpose, of some concessions of Protestant writers, that we mean at present to advert. In follow- ing out this line of policy, Popish controversialists usually employ an artifice which I had formerly occasion to expose,—viz., taking _ the statements of the Reformers made in the earlier period of their labours, and directed against the general strain of the public . teaching, oral and written, that then generally obtained in the ‘Church of Rome, and comparing them with the cunning and cautious decrees of the Council of Trent upon the subject of justification. We are willing to confine our charge against the ‘Church of Rome, as such, at least so far as the sixteenth century _ is concerned, to what we can prove to be sanctioned by the Council of Trent; and, indeed, there was not in existence, at the com- -mencement of the Reformation, anything that could be said to be a formal deliverance upon the subject of justification to which the Church of Rome could be proved to be officially committed.
- But we must expose the injustice done to the Reformers, when
their statements, expressly and avowedly directed against the teaching then generally prevalent in the Church of Raines are re- " presented, as they often are, by modern Popish controversialists,— -and Méehler, in his Symbolism, with all his pretensions to candour and fairness, lays himself open to this charge,—as directed against the decrees of the Council of Trent, which were eee with much care and caution after the da liiéct had been fully discussed, _and in the preparation of which no small skill and ingenuity were
* Jurieu, in his “Prejugéz Légitimes | ency between the course taken by
contre le Papisme,” Part ii., c. xxy., | Nicole, and that taken by Arnauld,
pp. 307-10, points out the inconsist- | upon this subject.
6 JUSTIFICATION. [Cuar. XXI-
employed to evade the force of the arguments of the Reformers, and to conceal or gloss over what they had most successfully exposed. I had occasion formerly to quote or refer to an extract from Melancthon, written in 1536, when he was invited by Francis I. into France, in which he states the great improvement which had taken place, and the much nearer approach which had been exhibited to Protestant principles, in the statements then commonly made by Romanists upon justification and other sub- jects, as compared with those which prevailed when Luther began his work; and though the application which Melancthon made of this consideration was far from being creditable to his firmness or his sagacity, yet it was undoubtedly true, to a large extent, as a statement of a fact.
I may mention one striking and important instance in which the Council of Trent may be said to have modified and softened the erroneous doctrine which was previously prevalent in the Church of Rome upon this subject. It was the general doctrine of the schoolmen,—it was universally taught in the Church of
Rome at the commencement of the Reformation,—it was explicitly»
maintained by most of the Popish controversialists who, previously to the Council of Trent, came forward to oppose the Reformers, that men in their natural state, before they were justified and re- generated, could, and must, do certain good things by which they merited or deserved the grace of forgiveness and regeneration,— not indeed with the merit of condignity,—for that true and pro- per merit, in the strictest sense, was reserved for the good deeds of men already justified,—but with what was called the merit of congruity,—a distinction too subtle to be generally and popularly apprehended. Now, of this merit of congruity,—so prominent and important a feature of the Romish theology before and at the commencement of the Reformation, and so strenuously assailed
by Luther,—the Council of Trent has taken no direct notice
whatever. The substance, indeed, of the error may be said to be virtually retained in the decisions of the council upon the subject of what it calls dispositives or preparatives for justification ; but the error cannot be said to be very clearly or directly sanctioned ; and the council has made a general declaration, that* “none of those things which precede justification, whether faith or works,
* Sess. vi., C. viti.
2 i
Cnar, XXT.J JUSTIFICATION. 7
merit the grace of justification itself,”—a declaration, however, it should be observed, which has not prevented most subsequent io Romish writers fetta reviving the old doctrine of meritum de con- _ gruo before justification. If it be fair on the one hand that the Church of Rome, as such, should be judged by the decisions of the Council of Tr ent,—at least until it be shown that some other decision has been given by which the church, as such, was bound, _as by the bull Unigenitus,—it is equally fair that ihe Raoemens who wrote before the council, should be judged, as to the cor- rectness of their representations, by the doctrine which generally obtained in the Church of Rome at the time when these repre- sentations were made. But while this consideration should be remembered, in order that we may do justice to the Reformers, and guard against the influence of an artifice which Popish con- troversialists in modern times often employ in order to excite a prejudice against them, yet it is admitted that the question as to what is the doctrine of the Church of Rome upon the subject of justification must be determined chiefly by an examination of the decisions of the Council of Trent; and we hope to be able to show, that notwithstanding all the caution and skill employed in framing its decrees, they contain a large amount of anti-scriptural “error, bad that they misrepresent aid pervert the method of sal- pration in a way which, when viewed in connection with the natural tendencies of men, is fitted to exert a most injurious influence “upon the salvation of men’s souls. Turretine,* in asserting the importance of the differences between Protestants and the Church of Rome on the subject of justification, and adverting also to the “attempts which have been made by some Pestentant writers to ‘represent these differences as unimportant, has the following ‘statement: “ Licet verd nonnulli ex Pontificiis cordatioribus a veritatis yicti sanius ceteris de hoc articulo senserint et locuti Bint, Nec desint etiam ex Nostris, qui studio minuendarum Con- troversiarum ducti, censeant circa illum non tantam esse dissidii “materiam, et non paucas hic esse logomachias. Certum tamen est ‘non verbales, sed reales multas, et magni momenti controversias ‘nobis cum Pontificiis adhuc intercedere in hoc argumento, ut ex -sequentibus fiet manifestum.” Perhaps the fullest and most elaborate attempt made by any
* Loc. xvi., Quest. i., sec. ii.
8 JUSTIFICATION. [Cuap, XXT.
Protestant writer of eminence to show that the difference between Protestants and Romanists on the subject of justification is not. of very great importance, is to be found in the “Theses Theo- logic” of Le Blane, often called the Theses Sedanenses, because. their author was Professor of Theology in the French Protestant University of Sedan, at a period, however, shortly before the revocation of the Edict of Nantes, when the French Protestant. Church in general had very considerably declined from the doc- trinal orthodoxy of the Reformation, though it still contained some very able opponents of Popery, men qualified to contend with Bossuet, Arnauld, and Nicole. Le Blanc’s Theses is a work of much ingenuity and erudition; and it contains much matter that is fitted to be useful in the history of theology, though it should be read with much caution, as it exhibits a strong tendency on the part of its author to explain away, and to make light of, differences in doctrinal matters, which are of no small importance in the scheme of divine truth. The course of argument adopted by Le Blanc, in order to prove that there is no very material difference between Protestants and Romanists on this point, is not of a very fair or satisfactory kind, and gives us much more the impression of a man who had laid it down as a sort of task to him- _ self just to exert all his ingenuity, and to employ all his erudition, in explaining away the apparent differences among contending parties, than of one who was candidly and impartially seeking after the truth. It consists not so much in comparing the declara- tions of the Reformed confessions with those of the Council of Trent, as in collecting together all the best or most Protestant passages he could find in any Popish authors, and all the worst or most Popish passages he could find in any Protestant authors ; and then in showing that there was really no very great difference between them. The unfairness of this mode of argument is too obyious to need to be dwelt upon. It is easy to show that there have been Popish writers whose views upon religious subjects were sounder than those of their church, and Protestant writers whose views were less sound than those of the Reformers and their genuine followers. But the only important questions are: What is the doctrine of the Church of Rome upon this subject 2 in what respects does it differ from that taught by the Reformers, and embodied in the confessions of Protestant churches? in what way does the word of God decide wpon these differences? what is
.
Cur, XXI.J
JUSTIFICATION. 9
. their real value or importance? and how does it bear upon the _ general scheme of Christian truth, and upon the spiritual welfare
7
of men?”*
The more general considerations on which Le Blanc, and _ Grotius, and other men who have laboured to show that there is no very material difference between Protestants and the Church of Rome on the subject of justification, have mainly proceeded, are these,—that the Church of Rome ascribes the justification of sinners to the grace of God and to the merits of Christ, and
denies merit to men themselves in the matter.
Now, it is true
that the Council of Trent has made general statements to this effect ; but, notwithstanding all this, it is quite possible to show that their general declarations upon these points are virtually con- tradicted or neutralized,—practically at least, and sometimes even _ theoretically,—by their more specific statements upon some of the topics involved in the detailed exposition of the subject ; and that thus it can be proved, that they do not really ascribe the justifi-
cation of sinners wholly to the grace of God and to the work of
* Christ,—that they do not wholly exclude human merit, but ascribe
to men themselves, and to their own powers, a real share in the work of their own salvation; and that while this can be proved to be true of their doctrine as it stands theoretically, their scheme, _ as a whole, is also, moreover, so constructed as to be fitted, when _ viewed in connection with the natural tendencies of the human _ heart, to foster presumption and self-confidence, to throw obstacles in the way of men’s submitting themselves to the divine method
intended to accomplish,
_ of justification, and to frustrate the great end which the gospel scheme of salvation was, in all its parts, expressly designed and , viz., that, as our Confession of Faith
says, “both the exact justice and the rich grace of God might be glorified in the justification of sinners.”
* Tt is amusing and instructive to
observe the use to which Nicole turns
- the labours of Le Blanc in this matter,
in his ‘‘ Préjugés Légitimes contre les Calvinistes,” tome i., pp. 269, 274-6. Animadversions on Le Blanc in this matter are to be found in Witsius De (icon. Foed., Lib. iii., ¢. viii., secs. xlix.-lv., and De Moor Comment. in Marck. Compend., tom. iv., pp. 732-3, 753; Owen, vol. xi., pp. 84-5, 161
(or, in original edition, pp. 87, 179). For an exposure of other attempts to represent the differences between Protestants and Romanists on the sub- ject of justification as unimportant, see the controversy between Grotius and Andrew Rivet.—Rivet’s ‘* Vin- dicize Evangelice,” and Heidegger’s ‘¢ Dissertationes,” tom. i., Dissertatio Xi, Dues t West. Con., c. xi., sec. 3.
, 10 JUSTIFICATION. [Cuar. XXII.
See. 1—Popish and Protestant Views.
In dealing with the subject of justification, we must, first of all, attempt to form a clear and correct apprehension of what is the doctrine of the Church of Rome upon this topic, as opposed to that which the Reformers deduce from the word of God> Justification, it is admitted on both sides, is descriptive generally~ of the change or changes, in whole or in part, that must take place in respect of men individually, in order to their escaping from the evils of their natural condition, and attaining to happi- ness and heaven. The nature of the change or changes necessary must depend upon the actual features of men’s natural condition, the evils from which they must be delivered. And the way and manner in which they are brought about must be somewhat regu- lated by the natural powers or capacities of men themselves to procure or effect them, or to assist in procuring or effecting them. It is admitted, also, that the two leading features of men’s natural condition, which render salvation necessary, and must in some measure determine its character, are guilt and depravity,—or liability to punishment because of transgression of God’s law, and a tendency or inclination, more or less powerful and pervading, to violate its requirements and prohibitions. The corresponding changes, called graces, because admitted to be in some sense God’s gifts, and called the blessings or benefits of redemption, because admitted to be in some sense procured for men by what Christ has done for them, are an alteration upon men’s state or condition in relation to God and His law, whereby their guilt is cancelled, their sins are pardoned, and they are brought into a state of acceptance and favour; and a change upon their actual moral character, whereby the tendency to sin is mortified and subdued, and a state of heart and motive more accordant with what God’s law requires is produced. Thus far, and when these general terms are employed, there is no material difference of opinion; though the second change,—that upon men’s moral character,—is usually called by Protestants the regeneration or renovation of man’s moral nature, and by Papists the infusion of righteousness or justice,—righteousness or justice denoting, in their sense of it, actual conformity to what God requires, either in point of internal character (justitia habitualis) or of outward actions (justitia actualis),
ri - POPISH AND PROTESTANT VIEWS. 11
It is admitted, further, that these changes upon men’s state -and character, necessary to their salvation acd ultimate happiness, are to be traced, in general, to the grace or kindness of God, who confers or ar them, and to che work of Christ, who in some way has procured or purchased them for men, ‘And the sum -and substance of all that the Reformers demanded, as necessary to the pure preaching of the gospel,—the scriptural exposition of the leading principles of the method of salvation,—was, that the conceded ascription of these changes to the grace of God and the work of Christ, should be literally and honestly maintained, according to the proper import of the words, and should be fully carried out, in the more detailed exposition of the subject, without any other principles or elements being introduced into it which might virtually and practically, if not formally and theoretically, involve a denial or modification of them; while the great charge which they adduced against the Church of Rome was, that, in their fuller and more minute exposition of the way and manner In which these changes were effected upon men individually, they did introduce principles or elements which, more or less directly, deprived the grace of God and the work of Christ of the place and influence which the sacred Scriptures assigned to them. As the change upon men’s state and condition from guilt and condemnation to pardon and acceptance is, substantially, a change in the aspect in which God regards them, or rather in the way in which He resolves thenceforth to deal with them, and to treat them, it must, from the nature of the case, be an act of God, and it must be wholly God’s act,—an act in producing or effecting which men themselves cannot be directly parties; and the only way in which they can in any measure contribute to bring it about; is by their meriting it, or doing something to deserve it, at God’s hand, and thereby inducing Him to effect the change or to perform the act. It was as precluding the possibility of this, that the Reformers attached so much importance to the doctrine which we formerly had occasion to explain and illustrate,—viz., that all the actions of men previous to regeneration are only and wholly sinful; and it was, of course, in order to leave room for men in some sense meriting gifts from God, or deserving for themselves the blessings which Christ procured for mankind, that the Council of Trent anathematized it. The other great change is an actual effect wrought upon men
12 JUSTIFICATION. [Cuar. XXT.,
themselves, of which they are directly the subjects, and in produc-. ing or effecting which there is nothing, in the nature of the case, , though there may be in the actual character and capacities of men, to prevent them from taking a part. The Protestant doctrine of ' men’s natural inability to will anything spiritually good, which has; been illustrated in connection with the doctrine of original sin, of course precludes them from doing anything that can really improve: their moral character in God’s sight, until this inability be taken: away by an external and superior power ; while the doctrine of the Council of Trent about man’s freedom or power to will and do good remaining to some extent notwithstanding the fall, which
forms part of their decree on the subject of justification, paves the way, and was no doubt so intended, for ascribmg to men them-
selves some real efficiency in the renovation of their moral natures.
From the view taken by the Church of Rome of the nature
and import of justification, the whole subject of the way and man-
ner in which both these changes are effected, in or upon men in-
dividually, was often discussed in the sixteenth century under this
one head ; though one of the first objects to which the Reformers
usually addressed themselves in discussing it, was to ascertain and
to bring out what, according to Scripture usage, justification really
is, and what it comprehends. The decree of the fathers of Trent
upon this important subject (session vi.), comprehended in sixteen
chapters and thirty-three canons, is characterized by vagueness
and verbiage, confusion, obscurity, and unfairness. It is not very
easy on several points to make out clearly and distinctly what
were the precise doctrines which they wished to maintain and
condemn. Some months were spent by the Council in consulta-
tions and intrigues about the formation of their decree upon this
subject. And yet, notwithstanding all their pains,—perhaps we
should rather say, because of them,—they have not brought out a very distinct and intelligible view of what they meant to teach
upon some of its departments. F
The vagueness, obscurity, and confusion of the decree of the
Council of Trent upon this subject, contrast strikingly with the
clearness and simplicity that obtain in the writings of the Refor-
mers and the confessions of the Reformed churches regarding
it. There were not wanting two or three rash and incautious
expressions of Luther’s, upon this as upon other subjects, of
which, by a policy I formerly had occasion to expose, the
2
fe ' ‘Sze. TJ POPISH AND PROTESTANT VIEWS. 13
Council did not scruple to take an unfair advantage, by intro- ducing some of them into their canons, in a way fitted to excite an unwarrantable prejudice against the doctrine of the Reformers. And it is true that Luther and Melancthon, in some of their earlier works, did seem to confine their state- ments, when treating of this subject, somewhat too exclusively to the act of faith by which men are justified, without giving sufficient prominence to the object of faith, or that which faith apprehends or lays hold of, and which is the ground or basis of God's act in justifying,—viz., the righteousness of Christ. But though their views upon this subject became more clear and en- larged, yet they held in substance from the beginning, and brought out at length, and long before the Council of Trent, most fully and clearly the great doctrine of the Reformation,—viz., that justi- fication in Scripture is properly descriptive only of a change upon men’s legal state and condition, and not on their moral character, though a radical change of character invariably accompanies it ; that it is a change from a state of guilt and condemnation to a state of forgiveness and acceptance; and that sinners are justified, or become the objects of this change, solely by a gratuitous act of God, but founded only upon the righteousness of Christ (not on any righteousness of their own),—a righteousness imputed to them, and thus made theirs, not on account of anything they do or can do to merit or procure it, but through the instrumentality of faith -alone, by which they apprehend or lay hold of what has been pro- vided for them, and is freely offered to them. Let us now attempt to bring out plainly and distinctly the ‘doctrine which the Council of Trent laid down in opposition to these scriptural doctrines of the Reformers. The first important “question is, what justification is, or what the word justification means; and upon this point it must be admitted that the doctrine of the Council of Trent is sufficiently explicit. It defines* justi- fication to be “translatio ab co statu, in quo homo-nascitur filius primi Ade, in statum gratiz et adoptionis filliorum Dei per secundum Adam Jesum Christum, salvatorem nostrum,”—words which, in their fair and natural import, may be held to include under justification the whole of the change that is needful to be effected in men in order to their salvation, as comprehending their
* Segs. vi., C. iv.
'
14 JUSTIFICATION. [Cuar. XXI) deliverance both from guilt and depravity. But that this is the meaning which they attached to the word justification,—that they. regarded all this as comprehended under it,—is put beyond all doubt, by what they say in the seventh chapter, where they ex- pressly define justification to be, “non sola peccatorum remissio, sed et sanctificatio et renovatio interioris hominis per voluntariam susceptionem gratie et donorum.” Justification, then, according to the doctrine of the Church of Rome, includes or comprehends
i not only the remission of sin, or deliverance from guilt, but also 1 the sanctification or renovation of man’s moral nature, or deliver- ance from depravity. In short, they comprehend under the one name or head of justification, what Protestants—following, as they believe, the guidance of Scripture—have always divided into the two heads of justification and regeneration, or justification and jor sanctification, when the word sanctification is used in its widest sense, as descriptive of the whole process, originating in regenera- tion, by which depraved men are restored to a conformity to God’s moral image. Now, the discussion upon this point turns wholly upon this question, What is the sense in which the word justifica- tion and its cognates are used in Scripture? And this is manifestly a question of fundamental importance, in the investigation of this whole subject, inasmuch as, from the nature of the case, its de- cision must exert a most important influence upon the whole of men’s views regarding it. At present, however, I confine myself to a mere statement of opinions without entering into any exami- nation of their truth, as I think it better, in the first instance, to bring out fully at once what the whole doctrine of the Church of Rome upon this subject, as contrasted with that of the Reformers, really is.
It may be proper, however, before leaving this topic, to advert to a misrepresentation that has been often given of the views of the Reformers, and especially of Calvin, upon this particular point. When Protestant divines began, in the seventeenth century, to corrupt the scriptural doctrine of justification, and to deviate from the doctrinal orthodoxy of the Reformation, they thought it of importance to show that justification meant merely the remission or forgiveness of sin, or guilt, to the exclusion of, or without comprehending, what is usually called the acceptance of men’s persons, or their positive admission into God’s favour,—or their receiving from God, not. only the pardon of their sins, or im-
Sec. I.] POPISH AND PROTESTANT VIEWS. 15
ite Ree
munity from punishment, but also a right or title to heaven and eternal life. And in support of this view, these men appealed to the authority of the Reformers, and especially of Calvin. Now it is quite true, that Calvin has asserted again and again that _ justification comprehends only, or consists in, the remission or for- giveness of sin or guilt. But I have no doubt that a careful and deliberate examination of all that Calvin has written upon this point,* will fully establish these two positions,—first, that - when Calvin asserted that justification consisted only in the remission of sin, he meant this simply as a denial of the Popish doctrine, that it is not only the remission of sin, but also the ‘sanctification or renovation of the inner man,—this being the main and, indeed, the only error upon the point which he was called upon formally to oppose ; and, secondly, that Calvin has at least as frequently and as explicitly described justification as comprehend- ing, not only remission of sin in the strict and literal sense, but also positive acceptance or admission into the enjoyment of God’s _ fayour,—“ gratuita Dei acceptio,” as he often calls it,—including the whole of the change effected upon men’s state or legal condition in God’s sight, as distinguished from the change effected upon their character. This is one of the numerous instances, con- _stantly occurring, that illustrate how unfair it is to adduce the _ authority of eminent writers on disputed questions which had never really been presented to them,—which they had never entertained or decided; and how necessary it often is, in order to forming a correct estimate of some particular statements of an author, to examine with care and deliberation all that he has written upon d the subject to which they refer, and also to be intelligently ac- _ quainted with the way and manner in which the whole subject was discussed at the time on both sides. When the Council of Trent defined regeneration to be a component part or a constituent element ar justification, along with pardon or forgiveness, they were probably induced to do so partly because they could appeal to some of the fathers, and even to Augustine, in support of this use of the word, but also because their real object or intention was to make this sanctification, or
* Bishop O’Brien’s Attempt to Ex- | 346-7; (Note M., 2d ed., 1862 (Hds.).
plain and Establish the Doctrine of Bellarmine, “' De Justificatione,” Lib. Justification by Faith only, in Ten | ii., c. i., admits this in regard to Cal- Sermons; London, 1833; Note 12, pp. | vin.
] 16 JUSTIFICATION. ~ [Cnar. XXT. infused or inherent righteousness, as Romanists commonly call. it, the cause or ground of the forgiveness of sin. A change of legal state, and a change of moral character, are things so mani- festly different in their own nature, that they could scarcely avoid attempting some separate explanation of them, and of the way in which they were conferred or effected, even though they might regard them as both comprehended under the name justifica-_ tion. The question, Upon what ground or consideration does_ God forgive men’s sins? or, in other words, To what is it that He has regard, when, with respect to any individual, He passes an act of forgiveness ?—this question, viewed by itself as a distinct independent topic, is obviously one which requires and demands an answer, whether the answer to it may exhaust the exposition of the subject of justification with reference to its cause or not. The Reformers, after proving from the word of God that justi- fication, according to Scripture usage, described only a change of — state, and not a change of character, strenuously demanded that this question, as to the cause or ground of forgiveness, or as to what it was to which God had respect, when, in the case of any individual, He cancelled his guilt, and admitted him into the enjoyment of His favour and friendship, should be distinctly and explicitly answered ; and, accordingly, Protestant divines in gene- ral, when they are discussing the subject of justification, under-— stood in the limited scriptural sense of the word, and explaining the doctrine of the Church of Rome upon the subject, make it their object to extract from the decree of the Council of Trent any materials that bear directly upon this point. The council, indeed, have not presented this subject nakedly and distinctly, as in fairness they ought to have done, but have made use of their general definition of justification, as compre- hending also regeneration, for involving the whole subject in a considerable measure of obscurity. What may be fairly deduced from their statements as to the cause or ground of forgiveness or pardon, viewed as a distinct topic by itself, is this: After de- fining justification to be not only the remission of sins, but also the sanctification and renovation of the inner man, they proceed to explain the causes of this justification; and in doing so, they make a very liberal use of scholastic phrases and distinctions. The final cause, they say, is the glory of God and Christ, and eternal life; the efficient cause is God (Deus misericors) exercis-
: ‘Sec.I.] POPISH AND PROTESTANT VIEWS. 17
a
<i
“ing compassion ; the meritorious cause is Jesus Christ, who by His sufferings and death merited justification for us, and satisfied the Father in our room; the instrumental cause is the sacrament of baptism; and “the only formal cause is the righteousness (justitia) of God, not that by which He Himself is righteous, but that by which He makes us righteous, by which we, receiving it from Him, are renewed in the Spirit of our mind, and are not only reckoned or reputed, but are called and are truly righteous.” In this last statement of the Council about the formal cause of justi- fication being only an actual righteousness which God gives us or infuses into us, and which thereby comes to be inherent in us, it would seem as if they had tacitly intended to describe, as they ought to have done openly and plainly, rather the formal cause or ground of forgiveness, or of the change of state, than of justifica- tion in their own wide sense of it; for it is evident that the righteousness, or actual personal conformity of character to God’s law, which He bestows upon men by His Spirit, cannot be, as they assert it is, the formal cause of that sanctification or renova- tion of the inner man which they make a part of justification, and to which, therefore, everything that is set forth as a cause of justification must be causally applicable. This inherent righteous- ness, which God bestows upon men or infuses into them, might be said to be identical with the sanctification of the inner man, or, with “more strict exactness, might be said to be an effect, or result, or con- ‘sequence of it, but it cannot in any proper sense be a cause of it. This personal righteousness bestowed by God might, indeed, be
said to be the formal cause of forgiveness, if it were intended to convey the idea that it is the ground or basis on which God’s act ‘in forgiving rests, or that to which He has a regard or respect when He cancels a man’s guilt, and admits him to the enjoyment of His favour. And this is indeed the meaning which accords best with the general strain of the council’s statements. It is not “necessarily inconsistent, in every sense, with their making Christ and His work the meritorious cause of justification. In making Christ and His work the meritorious cause of justification, they, of course, in accordance with their definition of justification, make this the meritorious cause, equally and alike of forgiveness and of reno- vation, the two parts of which justification consists, or, as Bellar- mine expresses it, “mortem Christi, que pretium fuit redemp- tionis, non solim causam fuisse remissionis peccatorum, sed etiam
3—VOL. II. B
——— >
3
18 JUSTIFICATION. [Cuar. XXI.
interne renovationis.”* And this Protestants regard as in itself a great general scriptural truth, though they believe that it errs, both by excess and defect, when it is put forth as a part of the teaching of Scripture on the subject of justification. It errs by excess, in comprehending renovation as well as forgiveness under the head of justification ; and it errs by defect, in representing the work or righteousness of Christ as standing in no other or closer relation to forgiveness or acceptance than as being merely its meritorious cause. It is only with this second error that we have at present to do. The council not only makes the work or righteousness of Christ equally and alike the meritorious cause of forgiveness and renovation, but it expressly denies (can. x.) that men are formally justified by Christ’s righteousness, or, in other words, that Christ’s righteousness is the formal cause of our jus- tification ; and it expressly asserts, as we have seen, that the only
formal cause of our justification is the personal righteousness
which God bestows or infuses into men. Bellarmine carefully guards against the inference that, because the eleventh canon con- demns the doctrine that we are justified by the righteousness of Christ alone, it admitted by implication that we are justified formally by it at all.t
Now, it is plainly impossible to make one consistent and har-
monious doctrine out of these various positions, affirmative and
negative, which the council has laid down, except wpon the assump-
tion that the council really meant to teach that there is no direct and immediate connection between the work or righteousness of
Christ and the forgiveness of the sins of men individually; and _ to represent Christ as merely meriting the communication to men
of personal righteousness, and thereby, or through the medium of
_ this personal righteousness which He merited for them, indirectly
or remotely meriting the forgiveness of sin, of which this personal righteousness, infused and inherent, as they describe it, is the direct and immediate cause. That the Council of Trent really intended | to teach this doctrine, though it is brought out somewhat obscurely, jand though we are obliged to infer it from a careful comparison |of its different statements upon the subject, is clearly shown by Chemnitius in his valuable work, “Examen Concilii Tridentini,”
not only from an examination of the decrees themselves, but from
* De Justificatione, Lib. ii., cap. vi. t Ibid., Lib. ii., cap. ii.
Src. LJ POPISH AND PROTESTANT VIEWS. 19
the statements of Andradius, an eminent Popish divine, who was present at the council, and afterwards published a work in defence of its decisions.* That this is the doctrine which the council intended to teach, and that it is in consequence the ordinary recognised doctrine of the Church of Rome upon the subject, is confirmed, or rather established, by the consideration that the generality of Romish writers are accustomed, without any doubt or hesitation, to give this as the state of the question between them and Protestants upon this topic,—viz., Whether the cause of our justification be a righteousness inherent in us or not? or this, Whether the cause of our justification be a righteousness infused into and inherent in us; or an external righteousness,—that is, the righteousness of Christ,—imputed to us? And that in discussing this question, so stated, they just labour to produce evidence from Scripture that that to which God has an immediate respect or regard in forgiving any man’s sins, and admitting him to the enjoyment of His favour, is, not the righteousness of Christ, but _ an infused and inherent personal righteousness. As this is a point of some importance in order to a right apprehension of the doc- trine of the Church of Rome upon the subject, it may be proper to produce some evidence of this position.
Bellarmine says,f “ Status totius controversiz revocari potest ad hanc simplicem questionem, sitne formalis causa absolute justificationis, justitia in nobis inherens, an non?” and then he proceeds to show that the determination of this question in the affirmative at once overturns all the leading errors of the Refor- mers upon the whole subject of the causes and grounds of justifi- cation: “ Omnes refutantur, si probetur justitia inherens, quae ab- soluté et simpliciter justificet ;’ and more particularly, “Si justitia inherens est formalis causa absolutze justificationis, non igitur re-
- quiritur imputatio justiticee Christi.”
In like manner, Dens, in his “Theologia Moralis,” says,{ _ “Probo contra hereticos: quod justificatio formaliter fiat per in- fusionem gratiz habitualis inherentis anime, non vero per justi- tiam Christi nobis extrinsect imputatam.” Perrone also, in his
* Prelectiones Theologice,”§ lays down this proposition, as taught
* Chemnitii Exam. Con. Trid., p. + De Justificatione, Lib. ii., cap. i.
144, Ed. 1609; see also Bp. Dave- ft Dens’ Theol. Mor., tom. ii., p. 448. nant, Preelectiones de Justitia Habitu- § Perrone, Prelec. Theol., tom. 1., ali et Actuali, c. xxvii. col. 1398.
20 JUSTIFICATION. [CHap, X XT,
by the Council of Trent, and as being, therefore, de jide, or an essential binding article of faith: “Impii formaliter non justifi- cantur vel sola imputatione justitiae Christi vel sola peccatorum re- missione; sed justificantur per gratiam et caritatem, que in cordi- bus eorum per Spiritum Sanctum diffunditur, atque illis inheeret.” And, in answer to the Scripture statements adduced to prove that we are justified by the righteousness of Christ, he admits that we are justified by it as the meritorious cause; but denies that we are justified by it as the formal cause.
The most eminent Protestant divines have been quite willing to admit that these statements of Popish writers give a fair account of the state of the question, and have had no hesitation in under- taking the defence of the positions which this view of the state of the question assigned to them. They have not, indeed, usually attached much weight in this matter to the scholastic distinctions about the different kinds of causes; because, as Turretine says,* “in the matter of justification before God, the formal cause cannot be distinguished from the meritorious cause, since the formal cause, in this respect, is nothing else than that, at the sight of which, or from a regard to which, God frees us from condemnation, and accepts us to eternal life.” On these grounds Protestant writers have held themselves fully warranted in imputing to the Church of Rome the maintenance of this position,—viz., that that to which God has directly and immediately a respect or regard, in pardoning a man’s sins, and admitting him into the enjoyment of His favour, is a personal righteousness infused into that man, and inherent in him; while they have undertaken for themselves to — establish from Scripture the negative of this position, and to show that that which is the proper ground or basis of God’s act in for- giving or accepting any man,—that to which alone He has a re- spect or regard when He justifies him,—is the righteousness of Christ imputed to him.
It may be proper to mention, that among orthodox Protestant divines who have agreed harmoniously in the whole substance of the doctrine of justification, there may be noticed some differ- ences in point of phraseology on some of the topics to which we have referred, and especially with respect to the causes of justi- fication. These differences of phraseology are not of much im-
* Loc. xvi., Quaest. ii., sec. v.
\ ‘
}
a “ ~ Sec. LJ POPISH AND PROTESTANT VIEWS. oe
caf
portance, and do not give much trouble in an investigation of this subject. Calvin sometimes spoke of justification as consisting
_ in the remission of sins and the imputation of Christ’s righteous- ness.* But, by the imputation of Christ’s righteousness in this con-
{
nection, he seems to have meant nothing more than acceptance or positive admission into the enjoyment of God’s favour,—the be- stowal of a right or title to eternal life, as distinguished from, and going beyond, mere pardon. In any other sense,—and, indeed, in the strict and proper sense of the expression,—the statement is inaccurate ; for the imputation of Christ's righteousness does not stand on the same level or platform as the remission of sins, and of course cannot go to constitute, along with it, one thing desig- nated by the one term,—justification,—as is the case with accept- ance or admission into God’s favour. The imputation of Christ’s righteousness, correctly understood, is to be regarded as in the order of nature preceding both remission and acceptance, and as being the ground or basis, or the meritorious impulsive or formal cause, of them; or that to which God has respect when in any instance He pardons and accepts. t
Again, some orthodox divines have thought that the most accurate mode of speaking upon the subject, is to say that the formal cause of our justification is Christ’s righteousness im- puted; others, that it is the imputation of Christ’s righteousness ; and a third party, among whom is Dr Owen, in his great work on justification,t think that there is no formal cause of justifi- cation, according to the strict scholastic meaning of the expres-— sion; while all orthodox divines concur in maintaining against the Church of Rome, that, to adopt Dr Owen’s words, the right- eousness of Christ “is that whereby, and wherewith, a believing sinner is justified before God; or whereon he is accepted with God, hath his sins pardoned, is received into grace and favour, and hath a title given him unto the heavenly inheritance.” §
Having thus brought out the doctrine of the Church of Rome on the subject of the meaning, nature, and ground of justification,
§ For a full exposition of the dif- ferences of opinion and statement on the causes of justification, vide de Moor, tom. iv., pp. 682-90, and John Goodwin’s Imputatio Fidei, P. ii, ¢. iv.; Davenant, De Just. ; Appendix to Newman on Justification. ,
* A similar mode of speaking was
adopted by some Lutheran divines. Vide Buddeeus, Instit. Theol. Dogm., Lib. iv., c. iv., sec. vi.
+ Turret., Loc. xvi., Quaest. iv.
t Orme’s edition of Owen, vol. xi., pp: 257-292.
22 JUSTIFICATION. [CHar, XXI.
we proceed now to explain her doctrine as to its means and re — sults. And first with respect to the means of justification. The
Reformers were unanimous and decided in maintaining the doc- trine that faith alone justified; that men were justified by faith only; and this gave rise to a great deal of discussion between them and the Romanists,—discussions bearing not only upon the import and evidence of this general position, but likewise upon the meaning and nature of justifying faith, and upon the way and manner in which faith justifies, or in which it acts or operates in the matter of justification. By the position that faith alone justifies, the Reformers meant in general that faith was the only thing in a man himself, to the exclusion of all personal righteous- ness, habitual or actual, of all other Christian graces and of all good works, to which his forgiveness and acceptance with God are attributed or ascribed in Scripture,—the only thing in himself which is represented in God’s word as exerting anything like causality or efficiency in his obtaining justification. They did not hold that faith was the only thing which invariably accompanies justification, or even that it was the only thing required of men in order to their being justified ; for they admitted that repentance was necessary to forgiveness, in accordance with the doctrine of our standards, that, “to escape the wrath and curse of God due to us for sin, God requireth of us repentance unto life,” as well as “faith in Jesus Christ.”* But as repentance is never said in Scripture to
justify, as men are never said to be justified by or through repent-
- ance, or by or through anything existing in themselves, except
faith, the Reformers maintained that faith stood in a certain rela- tion to justification, such as was held by no other quality or feature in men’s character or conduct,—that it justified them,—nothing else about them did; that men were justified by faith, and could not be said to be justified by anything else existing in themselves, whatever might be its nature or its source.
They did not teach that this faith which alone justified was ever alone, or unaccompanied with other graces; but, on the con- trary, they maintain that, to adopt the words of our Confession, f “it is ever accompanied with all other saving graces, and is no dead faith, but worketh by love.” Calvin, in explaining this
_* In the Larger Catechism, Ques. + C. xi., sec ii. 153, repentance is placed before faith.
q 1] POPISH AND PROTESTANT VIEWS. 23 “matter, says,* “Hoe semper lectoribus testatum esse volo, quoties in hac questione nominamus solam fidem, non mortuam a nobis _ fing, et que per caritatem non operatur : sed ipsam statui unicam _ justificationis causam. Fides ergo sola est que justificet: fides _ tamen que justificat, non est sola.” It is a curious fact, that while many Romish writers, and others who haye corrupted the doctrine of Scripture upon this subject, have misrepresented the great doctrine of the Reformation, that faith alone justifies, as meaning or implying that nothing but faith is in any sense required of men in order to their being forgiven, or does in fact invariably exist in justified men, Bellarmine accurately and fairly lays it down as one of the leading differences between the Reformers and the Church of Rome on the subject of justifying faith, that the Reformers held, “fidem solam justificare, nunquam tamen posse esse solam,” whereas the Romanists taught, in full and exact contrast with this, “fidem non justificare solam, sed tamen posse esse solam.” f Again, the Reformers did not ascribe to faith, in the matter of justification, any meritorious or inherent efficacy in producing the result, but regarded it simply as the instrument or hand by which a man apprehended or laid hold of, and appropriated to himself, the righteousness of Christ ; and it was only in that very general and, strictly speaking, loose and improper sense, which was consistent with this view of its function and operation in the matter, that they called it, as Calvin does in the extract above
* quoted from him, the cause of justification. Such were the clear
and explicit doctrines of the Reformers on the subject of the ‘means of justification, its relation to faith, and the place and function of faith in the matter.
On all these topics the Council of Trent has spoken with some degree of obscurity and unfairness, insinuating misrepre- sentations of the real doctrines of the Reformers, and bring-
-ing out somewhat vaguely and imperfectly what they meant to teach in opposition to them. In accordance with their princi- ples, they could not admit that there was any sense in which faith alone justified, or in which men were justified by faith only; for, as we have seen, they held that inherent personal righteousness was the only formal cause, and that baptism was
* Calvini Antid. in Sextam Ses-| _ + Bellarm., De Justificat., Lib.i., c.
sionem ; in Canon. x1. iii.
24 JUSTIFICATION. (Cuap; XXT.
the instrumental cause of justification. Accordingly, they denied* — that a sinner is justified by faith alone, in such wise as to mean that nothing else is required to co-operate in order to the ob-—
taining the grace of justification. Now, this is quite equivalent
to denying that in any sense faith alone justifies: for anything _
which acts or operates in order to obtaining justification, may be
said to justify; and as the canon clearly implies that there is_
always something else conjoined with faith in the matter of justi- fication, different from faith itself, and equally with it operating in order to obtain justification, it follows that in no sense does faith alone justify. And, in accordance with this view, they explain the sense in which they understand the apostle’s ascrip- tion of justification to faith,t—in which alone they admit that
faith justifies at all,—in this way, “ We are therefore, or for this" reason, said to be justified by faith, because faith is the beginning
of human salvation, the foundation and the root of all justifica- tion.” By this they mean that faith justifies, or is said to justify, because, or inasmuch as, it is the chief means of producing that personal righteousness which is the true cause or ground of justi- fication; or, as it is thus rather oddly and awkwardly explained by Bellarmine: “ Fidem non tam justificare, quam justificare, ut initium, et radicem primam justificationis; hinc enim sequetur non ipsam solam justificare, sed sic eam agere in hoc negotio, quod suum est, ut etiam ceteris virtutibus locum relinquat.”’ The title
;
‘
tT ;
of the chapter from which this curious extract is taken is, “ Fidem
justificare, sed non solam, idem enim facere timorem, spem, et di- lectionem,” etc. And he had previously laid down this as one of the leading differences between Protestants and Romanists on the subject of justifying faith: “Quod ipsi (the Protestants) solam fidem justificare contendunt, nos ei comites adjungimus in hoe ipso officio justificandi, sive ad justitiam disponendi.” §
Indeed, the function or place which the Council of Trent assigns to faith in this matter, is rather that of preparing or dis- posing men to receive justification, than of justifying ; and even in this subordinate work of preparing or disposing men to receive justification, they give to faith only a co-ordinate place along with half a dozen of other virtues. For the sake of clearness, I
* De Justificat., can. ix. { Bellarm., De Justificat., Lib. i.
T Sess. vi., C. viii. cap. xiii. :
§ Ibid., cap. iii.
Bic, 1] POPISH AND PROTESTANT VIEWS. 25
‘shall explain this important point in the words of Bellarmine,
rather than in the vague and obscure verbiage which the Council
of Trent has thought proper to employ upon this subject. He ‘says, “Adversarii . . . . sola fide justificationem acquiri, sive
-apprehendi docent: Catholici contra, ac prasertim Synodus ipsa Tridentina (quam omnes Catholici, ut magistram sequuntur) sess. Vi., cap. vi. Septem actus enumerat, quibus impii ad justitiam disponuntur, videlicet fidei, timoris,: spei, dilectionis, poenitentiz, propositi suscipiendi sacramenti, et propositi nove vite, atque observatonis mandatorum Dei.”* So that men, before they can obtain the forgiveness of their sins and the renovation of their natures—the two things in which, according to the Church of Rome, justification consists,—must exercise faith, fear, hope, love, penitence, and have a purpose of receiving the sacrament, and of leading a new and obedient life; and, even after they have done all this, they are not justified, for none of these things justifies, but only prepares or disposes to justification.
This subject, of men disposing or preparing themselves to receive justification, is an important feature in the theology of the Church of Rome, and may require a few words of explanation. First of all, it is needed only in adults: all baptized infants receive in baptism, according to the doctrine of the Church of Rome, for- giveness and regeneration, without any previous disposition or pre-
-paration,—God in baptism first renewing, and then forgiving them, and thus completely removing from them all the effects of original sin,—a doctrine, the falsehood and injurious influence of which has been already exposed ; but all adults must be disposed or prepared, by exercising the seven virtues, as Romanists commonly call them, above enumerated, before they receive either forgive- ness or renovation. We are not called upon at present to advert to the absurdity of the alleged antecedency of all these virtues or -graces to the sanctification of the inner man, in which partly justification consists; but when we find faith placed in the very same relation to justification, as the other virtues with which it is here classed, and even then not allowed to justify, or to be that by which men are justified, but merely to prepare or dispose men for receiving justification, we are irresistibly constrained to ask, if this is anything like the place assigned to it, in the matter of
* Bellarm., De Justificat., Lib. i., cap. xii.
: ' 26 JUSTIFICATION. [Cuar, XXI.
justification, by the Apostle Paul when he was expounding the way of a sinner’s salvation to the Christians at Rome ?
But we must at present consider what the modern Church of Rome teaches about this matter of disposing or preparing men for justification,—a subject on which the apostle certainly left the Roman Christians of his day in profound ignorance, though he seems to have intended to open up to them the whole doctrine of justification, so far as he knew it. The Council of Trent gives us scarcely any direct or explicit information as to what they mean by these seven virtues disposing or preparing men for justification, except that it is necessary that they should all exist, and be exer- cised, before men are forgiven and renewed, and that they exert some influence in bringing about the result. It tells us, however, that none of those things that precede justification, whether faith or works, merit or deserve the grace of justification itself ; and this had so far an appearance of deference to plain scriptural princi- ples. It is not, however, by any means certain,—nay, it is very improbable,—that the council, by this declaration, meant to take away from these preliminary and preparatory virtues anything but the strict and proper merit of condignity, which they reserved for the good works of justified men. The council does not, indeed, formally sanction, as I have already mentioned, the dis- tinction which prevailed universally in the Church of Rome at the time when the Reformation commenced, between merit of congruity and merit of condignity. But neither has it formally nor by implication condemned it; and it is certain that most Romish writers since the council have continued to retain and to apply this distinction,—have regarded the decision which we are considering, merely as denying to these dispositive or preparatory works merit of condignity, and have not scrupled, notwithstand- ing this decision, to ascribe to them merit of congruity; or, in other words, to represent them as exerting some meritorious effi- cacy, though in a subordinate sense, and of an imperfect kind, in procuring for men justification. Bellarmine fully and explicitly asserts all this. He maintains that the decision of the council, that these dispositive and preparatory works do not merit justifi- cation, means merely that they do not merit it ex condigno,—con- tends that they do merit it ex congruo,—and asserts that this is the view taken by most, though not by all, Romish writers, both as to the truth of the case and the real import of the decision of
‘Src. 1] POPISH AND PROTESTANT VIEWS. 27
the council; from all which we are warranted in concluding, that the decision of the council, denying merit to those things which precede justification, is equivocal, and was intended to be equivo- cal and deceptive. Bellarmine for one,—and this is true also of the generality of Romish writers,—goes so far as to assert explicitly that these virtues are meritorious causes of justification ; and he was fully warranted in doing so, if it be true that the Council of Trent did not deny, or intend to deny, to them merit of con- gruity; and if it be also the general doctrine of the Church of Rome, as he asserts it is, “ Potius fundari meritum de congruo in aliqua dignitate operis, quam in promissione.” *
There was also a great deal of controversy between the Re- formers and the Romanists on the definition and nature of justi- fying faith, and the way and manner in which it acted or operated in the matter of justification. The Reformers generally con- tended that justifying faith was fiducia, and had its seat in the will; and the Romanists that it was merely assensus, and had its seat in the understanding. This is a subject, however, on which it must be admitted that there has been a considerable difference of opinion, or, at least, of statement, among orthodox Protestant divines in more modern times; and which, at least in the only sense in which it has been controverted among Protestants who were in the main orthodox, does not seem to me to be determined in the standards of our church. While the Reformers unanimously and explicitly taught that faith which alone justified did not justify by any meritorious or inherent efficacy of its own, but only as the instrument of receiving or laying hold of what God had provided, —had freely offered and regarded as the alone ground or basis on which He passed an act of forgiveness with respect to any indivi- dual, viz., the righteousness of Christ,—the Council of Trent can scarcely be said to have determined anything positive or explicit as to the office or function of faith in justification, or as to the way and manner in which it can be said to justify, beyond what is contained in the statement formerly quoted, viz., that we are said to be justified by faith for this reason, because faith is the begin- ning of human salvation, the foundation and the root of all justi- fication. There is little information given us here except this,
* Bellarm., De Justificat., Lib. i., c. xxi. See also Lib. i., ¢. xvii. ; Lib: v.,
C. Xxi.
28 JUSTIFICATION. | (Cuar. XXT
that the reason why Scripture assigns so much prominence to faith, in the matter of justification, is, because faith is the chief means of originating and producing Christian graces and good. works; while, at the same time, it’ should be remembered that Romanists teach, as we have seen, that it does not necessarily and invariably produce them, as Protestants hold, but that it may exist alone or unaccompanied by them.
But while the Council of Trent does not formally and expli- citly teach more than this upon this point, there is nothing in the decree to preclude, and much in the general scope and spirit of its statements to countenance, the doctrine which has unquestionably been held by the great body of the most eminent Romish writers, viz., that faith has in itself some real and even meritorious efficacy, —i.e., meritum de congruo, as already explained,—in disposing to, and in procuring or obtaining, justification. This doctrine is thus expressed by Bellarmine, who lays it down as the doctrine of the Church of Rome, “ Fidem etiam a caritate disjunctam, alicujus esse pretii, et vim habere justificandi per modum dispositionis, et impe- trationis ;”* and again, “ Fidem impetrare justificationem, . . . ac per hoc justificare per modum dispositionis ac meriti;” and again, after stating fairly enough the doctrine of the Reformers in this way, “Fidem non justificare per modum cause, aut dignitatis, aut meriti, sed solum relative, quia videlicet credendo accipit, quod Deus promittendo offert,” he thus states in contrast the doctrine of the Church of Rome, “ Fidem justificare impetrando, ac pro- merendo . . . justificationem ;” and again, “Fidem impetrare, atque aliquo modo mereri justificationem ;’’+ while he applies similar statements to the other virtues, which, equally with faith, precede and dispose to justification, describmg them expressly as meritorious causes of justification.
We have now only to advert briefly to the differences between the Romanists and the Reformers on some points which may be comprehended under the general head of the results or consequences of justification ; and, first, we may explain the views respectively entertained by them, as to the way in which sins committed sub- sequently to justification are pardoned. The Reformers taught that these sins were pardoned upon the same ground, and through the same means, as those committed before justification,—viz.,
* Bellarm., De Justificat., Lib. i., cap. iii. t Lib. i., cap. xvii.
$0. 1.] POPISH AND PROTESTANT VIEWS. 29
upon the ground of Christ’s righteousness, and through the exer- cise of faith apprehending, or laying hold of, and appropriating it. As the Church of Rome teaches that fapdainn is the instrumental cause of justification, so she has invented another sacrament, and established it as the only channel through which pottbapt anal sins, as she commonly calls them, can be forgiven; for the Council of Trent anathematizes all who say * that “a man who has fallen after baptism is able to receive the justice which he has lost, by faith alone, without the sacrament of penance.” They do not, however, regard the forgiveness, which the sacrament of penance conveys in regard to post-baptismal sins, as so perfect and complete as that which baptism conveys in regard to the sins which preceded it: for they teach that the sacrament of penance, while it takes away all the guilt of mortal sins, in so far as this would otherwise have exposed men to eternal punishment, leaves men still exposed to temporal punishment, properly so called, for their mortal sins, and to the guilt, such as it is, of their venial sins; and thus needs to be supplemented by satisfactions, rendered either by sinners themselves, or by others in their room, and either in this life or in purgatory. These doctrines are plainly taught in the twenty-ninth and thirtieth canons; and as there is no room for doubt as to what the doctrine of the Church of Rome upon this point is, we need not at present further dwell upon it. _ The same observation applies to the second topic, which might be comprehended under this general head of the results or con- sequences of justification,—viz., this, that the Church of Rome teaches that it is possible for men, when once justified, to keep in this life wholly and perfectly the law of God; nay, even to go beyond this, and to supererogate, and that they can truly and pro- perly merit or deserve, with proper merit of condignity, increase of grace and eternal life. These doctrines, with the exception of that of works of supererogation,—which can be shown to be the doctrine of the church otherwise, though not so directly,—are taught clearly and unequivocally in the eighteenth, twenty-fourth, and thirty-second canons. The last topic which it is needful to advert to, in order to complete the view of the doctrine of the Church of Rome upon this important subject, is the certainty or assurance which believers
* Canon xxix.
30 JUSTIFICATION. [Cuar, XXTI.
have, or may have, or should have, of their being in a justified state, and of their persevering in it. This topic is explained in canons thirteenth, fourteenth, fifteenth, and sixteenth. The Council of Trent taught that no man can have any certainty or assurance that he will persevere and attain to eternal life, without a special revelation; but this topic was not much discussed at the time of the Reformation, and it belongs more properly to the controversy between the Calvinists and the Arminians. The dispute between the Reformers and the Romanists in connection with this matter turned mainly upon this question, whether men could or should have any certainty or assurance that they were at present in a justified state, and would, of course, be saved if they persevered in it. And upon this point many of the most eminent orthodox Protestant divines have been of opinion that both the Reformers and the Council of Trent carried their respective views to an extreme, and that the truth lay somewhere between them. The Romanists, in their anxiety to deprive men of all means of attaining to anything like certainty or assurance that they were in a justified and safe condition, and thus to keep them entirely dependent upon the church, and wholly subject to her control, denied the possibility of certainty or assur- ance; while the Reformers, in general, maintained its necessity, and, in order, as it were, to secure it in the speediest and most effec- tual way, usually represented it as necessarily involved in the very nature of the first completed act of saving faith. The generality of orthodox Protestant divines in more modern times have main- tained, in opposition to the Church of Rome, the possibility of / attaining to a certainty or assurance of being in a justified and re- , generated condition, and the duty of seeking and of having this “ certainty and assurance, as a privilege which God has provided 5 for His people, and a privilege the possession of which is fitted to ~ contribute greatly not only to their happiness, but to their holiness ; while they have commonly so far deviated from the views enter- tained by many of the Reformers, as to deny its necessity, except in the sense of obligation, and more especially to represent it as not necessarily involved in the exercise of saving faith: and this is the view given of the matter in the standards of our church. But this is a topic of comparatively subordinate importance, as it does not essentially affect men’s actual condition in God’s sight, their relation to Him, or their everlasting destiny, but rather their present peace and comfort, and the advancement of the divine life in their souls.
‘Sxo. IL] NATURE OF JUSTIFICATION. 31
_ There have thus been brought out many most important differ- ences between the doctrines of the Church of Rome and those generally held by orthodox Protestants, on the meaning and na- ture, the ground and cause, the means and instrument, the results and consequences, of justification; and we must now proceed to give some explanation of the way in which the Reformers estab- lished their doctrines upon these subjects, and proved that those of the Church of Rome were inconsistent with the word of God, and dangerous to the souls of men.
Sec. I.—Nature of Justification.
We shall advert briefly to the grounds on which we main- tain that justification is properly descriptive only of a change of state in men’s judicial relation to God, and to His law, as in- cluding forgiveness and acceptance or admission to God’s favour, in opposition to the Romish doctrine that it comprehends a change of character, the renovation of men’s moral nature, or, as Papists commonly call it, the infusion of an inherent righteousness. Justification is God’s act—it is He who justifies; and we must be guided wholly by the statements of His word in determining what the real nature of this act of His is. We must regard justification as just being what the word of God represents it to be; we must
understand the word in the sense in which it is employed in the sacred Scriptures. The question then is, In what sense are the words justification and its cognates used in Scripture; and more especially, should any variety in its meaning and application be “discovered there, in what sense is it employed in those passages in which it is manifest that the subject ordinarily expressed by it is most fully and formally explained? Now, the truth upon this point is so clear and certain in itself, and has been so generally admitted by all but Romanists, that it is unnecessary to occupy much time with the illustration of it. Jt has been proved innumerable times, by evidence against ‘which it is impossible to produce anything that has even plausi- bility, that the word justification is generally used in Scripture in what is called a forensic or judicial sense, as opposed to condem- nation; that it means to reckon, or declare, or pronounce just or righteous, as if by passing a sentence to that effect; and that it does not include in its signification, as the Council of Trent asserts,
} 32 JUSTIFICATION. | [Cuar. XXI, the making just or righteous, by effecting an actual change on the moral character and principles of men. The Council of Trent says that justification is not only the remission of sins, but also the sanctification and renovation of the inner man. But the inspired writers plainly do not ordinarily employ it to describe an actual change effected upon men’s character, but only a change effected upon their legal state or condition by a forensic or judicial act of the Justifier. It implies the pronouncing, more or less for- mally, of a sentence,—a sentence, not of condemnation, but of acquittal or acceptance. It has been alleged that the original and radical idea of the word évcacéw is to punish; and there are some considerations which favour this notion, though it cannot be ‘said to be established by satisfactory evidence. But even if this were admitted to be the primary or radical idea expressed by the word, there would be no great difficulty in tracing the process by which it came to acquire what seems to be the nearly opposite meaning it bears in the New Testament. When a man has had a sentence of condemnation passed upon him for an offence, and has, in consequence, endured the punishment imposed, he is free from all further charge or liability, and might be said to be now justified in the derived sense of the word, or to have now virtually a sentence of acquittal pronounced upon him. A punished person in this way virtually becomes a justified one, and the two notions are thus not so alien or contradictory as they might at first sight appear to be. And it should not be forgotten that, in the matter of the justification of a smner before God, there has been a punish- ment inflicted and endured, which is in every instance the ground or basis of the sinner’s justification. When the apostle says, as he is represented in our translation,* “ He that is dead is free from sin,” the literal, real meaning of his statement is, “ He that has died has been justified from sin,” Sedvcalwrat; and the import of this declaration (which furnishes, I think, the key to the interpretation of the chapter), is, that a man by dying, and thereby enduring the punishment due to his sin (which sinners of course do in their Surety, whose death is imputed to them), has escaped from all further liability, and has a sentence virtually pronounced upon him, whereby he is justified from sin.
But whatever might be the primary meaning of the word
* Rom, vi. 7.
‘Src, J NATURE OF JUSTIFICATION. 33
justify, and whatever the process of thought by which its meaning may have been afterward modified, it can be very easily and con- clusively proved, that both in the Old and in the New Testament it is ordinarily employed in a forensic or judicial sense, and means not to make or render righteous by changing the character, but to reckon, declare, or pronounce righteous by a sentence formal or virtual, changing the state or condition in relation to a judge and alaw. The Socinian system of justification is, in its general scope and tendency, very much akin to the Popish one; for both tend to assign to men themselves an influential and meritorious share in securing their own ultimate happiness; and yet even the Socinians admit that the word justify is used in the New Testa- ‘ment in a forensic sense, to denote the declaring or pronouncing men righteous. It is true that something else than a love of truth might lead them to concur with Protestants in the interpretation of this word; for the idea of God’s making men righteous by effecting some change upon their character, or what the Romanists call the infusion of righteousness,—which they allege to be in- cluded in justification,—does not harmonize with the Socinian system, according to which men do not need to be made righteous, since they have always been so,—do not need to have righteous- ness infused into them, since they have never existed without it. Almost the only man of eminence in modern times, beyond the pale of the Church of Rome, who has contended that the pro- per meaning of the word justify in Scripture is to make righteous, —i.e., to sanctify,—is Grotius, whose inadequate sense of the im- portance of sound doctrine, and unscriptural and spurious love of peace, made him ever ready to sacrifice or compromise truth, whether it was to please Papists or Socinians.* The course adopted upon this subject in Newman’s Lectures on Justification is rather curious ‘and instructive. Newman’s general scheme of doctrine upon this subject, though it was published some years before he left the Church of England, and though Dr Pusey issued a pamphlet for the purpose of showing that there was nothing Popish about it, is beyond all reasonable doubt identical, in its fundamental principles and general tendencies, with that of the Council of Trent and the Church of Rome, to which its author has since formally submit- ted himself. The fact, however, that the articles of the church
EE
* Grotius, Pref. ad Rom,
8—VOL. II. C
SN
; 34 JUSTIFICATION. [Cuar, XX.
to which he then belonged (and which, at the time, he does not seem to have had any intention of leaving), had fixed the mean- ing of the word justify to be, to “account righteous before God,” as well as perhaps some sense of the scriptural evidence in support of this view of its meaning, prevented him from openly adopting the definition which the Council of Trent gave of justification ; and obliged him to admit that the proper meaning of the word in Scripture is to declare or pronounce, and not to make or render, righteous. He feels, however, that this admission exposes him to some disadvantage and difficulty in the exposition and defence of his Popish system ; and he is, besides, greatly distressed at finding himself in the awkward position, to use his own words,* of ventur- ing “to prefer Luther in any matter even of detail to St Austin,” the former of whom, he says, was merely the founder of a school, or sect, while the latter was a father in the Holy Apostolic Church ;} and on these accounts he is obliged to devise some ex- pedient for practically and in substance withdrawing the conces- sion he had been compelled to make ; and it is this:t “To justify, means in itself “counting righteous,” but includes under its mean- ing “making righteous:” in other words, the sense of the term is “counting righteous ;” and the sense of the thing denoted by it is, making righteous. In the abstract, it is a counting righteous; in the concrete, a making righteous.” These words may probably be regarded as not very intelligible, but the general object or tendency of them is plain enough; and it is met and exposed simply by re- collecting that Scripture, being given by inspiration, and therefore a higher authority than even the unanimous consent of the fathers, just means what it says, and that by the terms which it employs it conveys to us accurate conceptions of the things denoted by them. The course pursued by Newman in this matter is fitted to impress upon us at once the difficulty, and the importance, for Popish purposes, of evading the clear scriptural evidence of the forensic sense of the word—justify.
But it is unnecessary to adduce in detail the scriptural evi- dence in support of the Protestant meaning of the word—justify. I may briefly advert, however, to the way in which Popish writers have attempted to meet it. »They do not deny that the word is
* Newman’s Lectures on Justifica- t Ibid. 67
tion, p. 70. 2d edition, _ t Ibid. p. 7L
Soa eg NATURE OF JUSTIFICATION. 35
sometimes, nay often, taken in Scripture in a forensic sense. Its “Meaning is too clearly and conclusively fixed by the context in “Some passages, especially in those in which it is formally opposed to the word condemn, to admit this position. But they usually contend that thisis not the only meaning which the word bears in the Scriptures,—that there are cases in which it means to make righteous,—and that, consequently, they are entitled to regard this idea as contained in its full scriptural import. Now, it is to be observed that the position which Protestants maintain upon this subject is not, that in every passage where the word occurs there exists evidence by which it can be proved from that passage alone, taken by itself, that the word there is used in a forensic sense, and cannot admit of any other. They concede that there are passages where the word occurs in which there is nothing in the passage itself, or m the context, to fix down its meaning to the sense of counting righteous, in preference to making righteous. Their position is this,—that there are many passages where it is plain that it must be taken in a forensic sense, and cannot admit of any other; and that there are none, or at least none in which the justification of a sinner before God is formally and explicitly spoken of, in which it can be proved that the forensic sense is inadmissible or necessarily excluded, and that it must be taken in the sense of making righteous. If these positions are true, then the Protestant view of the Scripture meaning and import of jus- tification is established ; for we are of course entitled to apply to those passages in which the sense of the word is not fixed by that particular passage, the meaning which it must bear in many “passages, and which cannot be shown to be certainly inadmissible in any one. This being the true state of the argument, Romanists, in order to make out their case, are bound to produce passages in which it can be shown that the word cannot be taken in a forensic sense, and must be regarded as meaning to make righteous. And this, accordingly, they undertake; usually, however, endeavour- ing in the first place to involve the subject in obscurity, by trying to show that there are various senses,—four at least,—in which the “ word justify is used in Scripture. The Romanists, of course, in this discussion are fully entitled to choose their own ground, and to select their own texts, in which they think they can prove that the forensic sense is inadmissible or necessarily excluded, and that of making righteous is required; while all that Protestants have
36 : JUSTIFICATION, [Cuap, XXI.
to do is merely to prove that the Romanists have not succeeded in conclusively establishing these positions.
The texts usually selected by Romanists for this purpose are the following :*—“ Moreover, whom He did predestinate, them He also called; and whom He called, them He also justified; and whom He justified, them He also glorified,’—where, as there is no explicit mention of regeneration or sanctification in this description of the leading steps of the process of the salvation of sinners, it is contended that this must be comprehended in the word justify, which seems to fill up the whole intermediate space between calling and glorifying. Again:+ “And such were some of you: but ye are washed, but ye are sanctified, but ye are justi- fied in the name of the Lord Jesus, and by the Spirit of our God,”—where the general scope of the passage, and the position of the word justified, it is alleged, show that at least it is not taken in a forensic sense. Again,t the apostle speaks of the “renewing of the Holy Ghost; which He shed on us abundantly through Jesus Christ our Saviour; that, being justified by His grace, we should be made heirs according to the hope of eternal life.” Again:§ “He that is righteous, let him be righteous still,’—the original of which in the “textus receptus,” as it is called, is cal o dtxatos StxatwOyntw ért. Now, some Protestant writers have ad- mitted that in these passages, or in some of them, the forensic use of the word dvxavow can be disproved; and Le Blanc, in the work which I formerly referred to, || and described, has produced all the concessions of this kind which he could discover, and has laboured himself to prove that these concessions could not have been fairly withheld, and cannot be refused without a very forced and unwar- rantable construction of the passages. Those Protestant divines who have been disposed to admit that in these passages, or in some of them, it can be shown that the word justify is not used in a forensic sense, usually contend that it is quite sufficient, in order to establish the Protestant doctrine, and to overthrow the Popish one, about the meaning of justification, to show that the forensic sense is that in which it is generally and ordinarily taken in Scripture, and that it is taken in that sense, and in no other, in those passages
* Rom. vili. 30. || Theses Theologicee Sedanenses.
t 1 Cor. vi. 11. De usu et acceptione vocis Justifi- t Titus iii. 5, 6, 7. candi in Scripturis et Scholis, pp.
§ Rev. xxii. 11. 255-63.
Z ie
2 DEC. IT. } NATURE OF JUSTIFICATION. ON
_ where the subject of the justification of a sinner before God is most fully and formally set forth. There is force in this view of the mat-
_ ter; and if these positions can be established, as they certainly can,
_ this is sufficient to show that it is unwarrantable to introduce into
_ the scriptural description of what the justification of a sinner is, any
other idea than that of a change of state in relation to God and to His law, even though one or two instances may occur in the Scrip- tures in which the word is used in a somewhat wider and larger sense. This consideration is sufficient to save Protestant commen- tators from any very strong temptation to pervert these passages from what may seem to be their true meaning, in order to wrest a weapon out of the hands of an opponent; and I use the word temptation here, because it should never be forgotten that the highest and most imperative duty of all honest investigators of Christian truth, is just to ascertain the true and real meaning of every portion of the inspired word of God. I cannot enter into a minute and detailed examination of those passages, and will make only one or two observations regarding them.
It will scarcely be disputed that, had these been the only pas- sages in the New Testament where the word justify occurred, the presumption would have been against it being taken in a forensic sense,—to describe a change of legal relation, the passing of a sentence of acquittal. But, from the explanation we have given of the conditions of the argument, it will be seen that much more than this must be proved in regard to them, in order to their being of any service to the Papists,—even that the forensic sense is clearly and conclusively shut out. Now, I think it has been
_ satisfactorily proved that this cannot be effected, and that, on the contrary, in regard to all the passages quoted,—except, perhaps, the one which occurs in the twenty-second chapter of the Revelation, —it can be shown, and without any violent and unwarrantable
-straining of the statements, that the ordinary and usual sense of the word in the New Testament is not clearly and necessarily excluded. In regard to the first of them,—that occurring in the eighth of the Romans,—it is contended that we have no right to assume, as the Popish argument does, that the apostle must necessarily have comprehended, in the description he gave, every step in the process of a sinner’s salvation, every one of the leading blessings which God bestows; that the train of thought which the apostle was pursuing at the time,—or, what is in substance the
38 JUSTIFICATION. ; [Cuar. XXT.
same thing, the context and scope of the passage,—did not require this, as Calvin has shown in his commentary upon it; and that even if we were to assume,—what, however, is not necessary, and is therefore, from the conditions of the argument, unwarrant- able,—that all the leading blessings of salvation must have been directly or by implication adverted to, we are under no more
necessity of supposing that regeneration, by which men are made
righteous, must be included under justification, than under voca- tion or glorification.
There is no serious difficulty in the passage quoted from the sixth of First Corinthians. Justify cannot here mean to make righteous,—i.c., it cannot be identical with, or comprehensive of, regeneration and sanctification ; for it is distinguished from them, while they are expressly mentioned. And as to the allegation that it cannot be here understood in a forensic sense, because it is in- troduced. after “washed and sanctified,” and is ascribed to the operation of the Holy Spirit, it is answered, that the inspired writers do not always, in other cases, restrict themselves to what may be called the natural order of time,—that the apostle’s. train of thought in the preceding context naturally led him to give prominence and precedency to washing and sanctification; while he was also naturally led on, in magnifying their deliverance and in enforcing their obligations, to introduce, as completing the description of what had been done for them, their justification, or deliverance from guilt and condemnation ; and that justification as well as sanctification may be, and is, ascribed to the Holy Spirit as well as to Christ, since it is He who works faith in them and thereby unites them to Christ, which union is the origin and the ground of all the blessings they enjoy. ;
Ask about this work
Ask a question and Waymark will prioritize this work, with related primary sources where helpful.