John Fletcher · The Works of John Fletcher (Checks to Antinomianism)
The Works of John Fletcher (Checks to Antinomianism)
by John Fletcher
About this work
Year
1772
Text preparation
Linguistically cleaned with LLM assistance. 675 applied changes.
Applied changes (675)
-
. → .
mechanical spacing repair: insert space after period before 'By'
-
! → !
remove space before exclamation mark
-
Tt is a → It is a
OCR misread 'I' as 'T'; context indicates 'It is a doubt'
-
1s → is
digit/letter fusion: '1s' should be 'is' in 'the fall and the recovery of man is attended with'
-
. → .
insert space after period
-
; → ;
remove space before semicolon
-
! → !
remove stray space before exclamation mark
-
. → .
missing space after period before 'our'
-
; → ;
Remove stray space before punctuation following closing quotation mark
-
; → ;
Remove stray space before closing quotation mark; punctuation belongs adjacent to the quote.
-
paSsages → passages
OCR misrecognized lowercase 'ss' as 'S'; word should be lowercase in context
-
raiTHFUL → faithful
chaotic case; context requires 'faithful'
-
is fo do → is to do
'fo' is OCR error for 'to'
-
1s → is
OCR digit/letter fusion of 'is' as '1s'
-
. → .
remove stray space before period
-
abuse;than → abuse; than
missing space after semicolon
-
HonovureD → Honoured
OCR garbling of 'Honoured' in salutation
-
ReEvEREND → Reverend
restore normal capitalization of 'Reverend'
-
Si1r → Sir
digit '1' fused into 'Sir'
-
. → .
period run together with following word; insert space
-
expects_faithfulness → expects faithfulness
underscores are OCR spacing artifacts; phrase reads naturally between 'works upon man' and 'from man'
-
EpyaZecde → ἐργάζεσθε
OCR garbled Greek word for 'work' cited in the Labour (ergazesthe) gloss
-
Epya2Zeode → Ergazesthe
OCR digit/letter fusion of Greek ἐργάζεσθε; restored transliteration
-
; → ;
stray space before punctuation; remove space, retain semicolon
-
Zec → zes
OCR misread of Greek letters in ἐργάζεσθε fragment; Zec corresponds to 'zes'
Showing 25 of 675.
Thus hoped those pious divines concerning Dr. Crisp: and thus I ence hoped also concerning his admirers. But, alas! experience has damped my hope; for, when they have been “calmly reasoned with,” they have shown themselves much more ready to unsay what they had said right, than what the doctor had said wrong; and to this day they publicly defend those.2ntinomian dotages, which the authors of Flavel’s preface could not believe Dr. Crisp could possibly mean, even when he preached and wrote them.
You express, honoured sir, a most extraordinary wish, p. 94. Speaking of Flavel’s Discourse upon Mental Errors, which is also called A Blow at the Root, you say, “I should have been glad could I have transcribed the whole discourse.” But as you have not done it, I shall give a blow at the root of your system, by presenting you with an extract of the second Appendix, which is a pretty large treatise full against Antinomianism.
“The design of the following sheets,” says that great Puritan divine, in the discourse you should be glad wholly to transcribe, “is to free the grace of God from the dangerous errors, which fight against it under its own colours; to prevent the seduction of some that stagger; and to vindicate my own doctrine. The Scripture, foreseeing there would arise such a sort of men in the Church as would wax wanton against Christ, and turn his grace into lasciviousness, has not only precautioned us in general to beware of such opinions as corrupt the doctrine of free grace: ‘Shall we continue in sin that grace may abound? God forbid:’ but has marked those very opinions by which it would be abused, and made abundant provision against them. As namely, (1.) All vilifying expressions of God’s holy law, Rom. vii. (2.) All opinions inclining men to the neglect of the duties of obedience, under pretence of free grace and liberty by Christ, James ii; Matt. xxv. © (3.) All opinions neglecting sanctification as the evidence of justification, which is the principal scope of St. John’s first epistle. “ Notwithstanding such is the wickedness of some, and weakness of others, that in all ages (especially in the last and present) men have notoriously corrupted the doctrine of free grace, to the great reproach of Christ, scandal of the world, and hardening of the enemies of the reformation. ‘ Behold, (says.Contzen the Jesuit,) the fruit of Protestantism, and their Gospel preaching.’
- The Gospel makes sin more odious than the law did, and discovers the punishment of it in a more dreadful manner. ‘For if the word spoken by angels was steadfast, and every disobedience received a just recompense of reward, how shall we escape if we neglect so great salvation? It shows us our encouragements to holiness greater than ever; and yet corrupt nature will still abuse it. The more luscious the food is, the more men are apt to surfeit upon it.
“This perversion of free grace is justly chargeable both upon wicked and good men. WickeEp MEN corrupt it designedly, that, by entitling God to their sins, they might sin the more quietly. So the Nicolaitans, and school of Simon; the Gnostics, in the very dawning of Gospel light; and he that reads the preface of learned Mr. Gataker’s book, will find that,some Antinomians of our days are not much behind the vilest of them. One of them cries out, ‘ Away with the law! It cuts off a man’s legs, and then bids him walk.’ Another says, ‘ That if a man, by the Spirit, know himself to be in a state of grace, thoug he commit murder,* God sees no sin in him.’ “ But others} there are, whose judgments are unhappily ininded with * those loose doctrines; yet being, 1 in the main GopLy PERSONS, they dare not take the liberty to sin, or live in the neglect of known duties, though their principles too much incline that way. But though they dare 1 not, others will, who imbibe corrupt notions from them; and the renowned piely of the authors will be no antidote against the danger; but make the poison operate the more powerfully, by receiving it in sucha vehicle. Now it is highly probable these men were charmed into these opinions upon such accounts as these:-— ‘I. Some of them might have felt in themselves the anguish of a perplexed conscience under sin, and not being able to live under the ter- rors of the law, might too hastily snatch at such doctrines which promise them relief and ease. (2.) Others have been induced to espouse these opinions from the excess of their zeal against the errors of the Papists. (3.) Others have been sucked into those quicksands of Antinomian errors, by fathering théir own fancies upon the Holy Spirit. (4.) And it is not unlike, but a comparative weakness of mind, meeting with a fervent zeal for Christ, may induce others to espouse such taking and plausible, though pernicious doctrines.
“Let all good men beware of such opinions and expressions as give a handle to wicked men to abuse the grace of God, which haply the author himself dares not do, and may strongly hope others may not do: but if the principle will yield it, it is in vain to think corrupt nature will not catch at it, and make a vile use, and dangerous improvement “For example: If such a principle as this be asserted before the world, ‘ That men need not fear that any or all the sins they commit shall do them any hurt:’{ let the author warn and caution his readers, [as the Antinomian§ author of that expression has done, | not to abuse this doctrine; it is to no purpose, the doctrine itself is full of dangerous consequences, and wicked men have the best skill to draw them forth to cherish their lusts. That which the author might design for the relief of the distressed, quickly turns into poison in the bowels of the wicked. Nor can we excuse it by saying any Gospel truth may be thus abused; for this is none of that number, but a principle that gives offence to the godly and encouragement to the ungodly. And so much as to the rise and occasion of Antinomian errors.
“JT. Let us view next some of the chief errors of Antinomians. (1.) Some make justification to be an eternal act of God, and affirm that the elect were justified before the world had a being. Others, that they were justified at the time of Christ’s death: with these Dr. Crisp,
- This is, I fear, the very doctrine of your fourth letter, where an impenitent murderer is represented as complete in Christ, &c. + Here my worthy opponent is exactly described by Flavel. t My worthy opponent has publicly advanced, not only that sin, even adultery and inurder, does not hurt the pleasant children, but that it even works for their ood. a § Dr. Crisp, who was publicly called an Antinomian by the Puritans, and his tenets loose, corrupt, and pernicious doctrine ; Antinomian dotages, gc.
- harmonizes. (2.) That justification by faith is no more than a manifestation to us, of what was done before we had a being. (3.) That men ought not to question whether they believe or no. (Salimarsh on Free Grace, p. 92, 95.) (4.) ‘That believers are not bound to mourn for sin, because it was pardoned before it was committed; and pardoned sin is no sin. (Eaton’s Honeycomb of Justification, p. 446.) (5.) That God sees no sin in believers, whatsoever sins they commit. (6.) That God is not angry with the elect, and that to say he smites them for their sins is an injurious reflection upon his justice. This is avouched generally in al] their writings. (7.) That by God’s laying our iniquities upon Christ, he became as completely sinful as we, and we as completely righteous as Christ. (Dr. Crisp, p. 270.) (8.) That no sin can do believers any hurt, nor must they do any duty for their own salvation. (9.) That the new covenant is not made properly with us, but with Christ for us; and that this covenant is all of it a promise, having no condition on our part. They do not absolutely deny that faith, repentance, and obedience are conditions in the new covenant; but say, they. are no conditions on our side, but Christ’s, and that he repented, believed, and obeyed for us. (Saltmarsh on Free Grace, p. 126.) (10.) They speak very slightingly of trying ourselves by marks and signs of grace. Saltmarsh calls it ‘a low, carnai way:” but the New- England Antinomians call it a fundamental error, to make sanctification an evidence of justification. They say, that the darker our sanc- tification is, the brighter is our justification. *‘T look upon such doctrines to be of a very dangerous nature; and their malignity and contagion would certainly spread much farther than it does, had not God provided two powerful antidotes.
“1. The scope and current of the Scriptures. They speak of the elect as ‘children of wrath’ during their unregenerate state. They frequently discover God’s anger, and tell us, his castigatory rods are laid upon them for their sins. They represent sin as the greatest evil; most opposite to the glory of God and good of his saints. They call the saints to mourn for their sins, &c. They put the people of God to the trial of their interest in Christ, by signs and marks from the divers branches of sanctification. They infer duties from privileges; and therefore the Antinomian dialect is a wild note, which the generality of serious Christians do easily distinguish from the Scripture language. : “2. The experience and practice of the saints greatly secure us from the spreading malignity of Antinomianism. They acknowledge that before their conversion they were equal in sin and misery with _ the vilest wretches in the world. They fear nothing more than sin.
They are not only sensible that God sees sin in them, but they admire his patience, that they are not consumed for it. They urge his commands and threatenings, as well as promises, upon their own hearts to promote sanctification. They excite themselves to duty and watchfulness against sin. They encourage themselves by the rewards of obedience, knowing their ‘labour is not in vain in the Lord.’ And he that shall tell them, their sins can do them no hurt, or their duties no good, speaks to them not only as a barbarian, but in such a language as their souls abhor. The zeal and love of Christ being kindled in their souls, they have no patience to hear such doctrines as so greatly derogate from his glory, under a pretence of honouring and exalting him.
It wounds and grieves their very hearts to see the world hardened in their prejudices against reformation, and a gap opened to all licentiousness. But notwithstanding this double antidote, we find, by daily experience, such doctrines too much obtaining in the professing world, Tantum religio suadere malorum. “ For my own part, He that searcheth my heart is witness, I would rather choose to have my right hand wither, and my tongue ret within my mouth, than to speak one word, or write one line, to cloud thé free grace of God. Let it arise and shine in its meridian glory. None owes more to it, or expects more from it, than I do; and what I write in this controversy is to vindicate it from those opinions, which, under pretence of exalting it, do really militate against it.”
Then follows a prolix refutation of the above-mentioned Antinomian errors, most of which necessarily flow from your second and fourth letters. When our pious author attacks them as a disciple of St. James, he carries all before him: but when he encounters them as an admirer of Calvin, his Hands hang down, Amalek prevails, and a shrewd logician could, without any magical power, force him to confess, that most of the errors which he so justly opposes are the natural consequences of wnconditicnal election, particular redemption, irresistible grace, Calvinian imputation of righteousness to impenitent murderers, the infallible perseverance of believers who defile their fathers’ beds, and, im a word, salvation finished for all the ‘pleasant children,” who go on frowardly in the way of their own heart. Thus it would appear that Calvinism is “the wpwrov evdog,” to use Mr. Flavel’s words, “The radical and prolific error from which most of the rest are spawned.”
He concludes his anti-Crispian treatise by the following truly Christian paragraph: “TI call the Searcher of hearts to witness that I have not intermeddled with this controversy of Antinomianism, out of any delight I take in polemic studies, or an unpeaceable contradicting humour, but out of pure zeal for the glory and truths of God, for the vindication and defence whereof I have been necessarily engaged therein. And having discharged my duty thus far, I now resolve to return, if God permit me, to my much more agreeable studies: still maintaining my Christian charity for those whom I oppose, not doubting but I shall meet those in heaven from whom I am forced in lesser things to dissent upon earth.”
While my heart is warmed by the love which breathes through the last words of Mr. Flavel’s book, permit me to tell you, that I cordially adopt them with respect to dear Mr. Shirley and yourself, hoping that if you think yourself obliged “ to cut off all intercourse and friendship with me” upon earth, on “account of what you are pleased to call my ‘“‘ dismgenuity and gross perversions,” you will gladly ascribe to the Lamb of God a common salvation truly finished in heaven, together with, honoured and dear sir, your most obedient servant, in the pure Gospel of St. James, J. FLrercuer.
LETTER V. To Richard Hill, Esq.
Honovurep anp Dear Sir,—I have hitherto endeavoured to show that the exploded doctrine of a second justification by works, (i. e. by the evidence or instrumentality of works,) in the day of judgment, is Scriptural, consonant to the doctrine of our Churok, and directly or indirectly maintained, as by yourself, so by all anti-Crispian Puritan. diyines, whenever they regard St. James’ holy doctrine more than Calvin’s peculiar opinions. I shall now answer a most important question which you propose about it, p. 149. You introduce it by these words:— ** You cannot suppose that when Mr. Shirley said, Blessed be God, neither Mr. Wesley nor any of his preachers, (Mr. Olivers excepted,) holds a second justification by works, he intended to exclude good works in an evidential sense.” Indeed, sir, I did suppose it; nor can I to this moment conceive how Mr. Shirley could lean toward Calvinism, if he were settled in St. James’ doctrine of justification by the evidence of works. You proceed :— ‘ Neither Mr. Shirley, nor I, nor any Calvinist that I ever heard of, deny that a smner is declaratively justified by works, both here and at the day of judgment.” You astonish me, sir. Why then do you at the end of this very paragraph, find fault with me for saying, that it will be absurd in a man, set on the left hand as a rebellious subject of our heavenly King, to plead the works of Christ, when his own works are called for, as the only evzdences according to which he must be justified or condemned? Why do you cry out in the fifth letter of your Review, “O shocking to tell! Horresco referens,’ &c. Why do so many Calvinists shudder with horror because I have represented our Lord as condemning, by the evidence of works, (agreeably to his own express doctrine, Matt. xxv,) a practical Antinomian, a canting apostate, who had no good works to be declaratively justified by in the day of judgment? Why do you maintain, that when David committed adultery and murder he was “ justified from all things; his sins past, present, and to come, were for ever and for ever cancelled?” And why do you (p. 70) call me a “ snake that bites the Calvinist ministers,” because I have exposed the Antinomianism of those preachers who, setting aside Christ’s doctrine of justification by the evidence of works in the last day, give thousands to understand, that they shall then be abundantly justified by righteousness imputed in Calvin’s way, and by nothing else? You go on:— “ Therefore, I say, if you utterly disclaim all human works, as the procuring, meritorious cause of justification, what need was there of addressing Mr. Shirley as you have done? Yea, what need was there of your making this point a matter of controversy at all? We are quite agreed both as to the expression and as to the meaning of it.”
Are we indeed quite agreed, both as to the expression of a second / 236 FOURTH CHECK TO ANTINOMIANISM. justification by works in the day of judgment and as to the meamng of it; to which I once more set my seal, viz. that we shall be justified, not by the merit, but by the evidence of works? What a pity is it then, that you did not find this out till you came to the 149th page of your book! It would probably have saved you the trouble of writing it, and me the thankless office of exposing it.
However, it is but right I should requite your candid concession by ~ answering your important question: ‘ What need was there of making this point, [ of justification by the evidence of works in the day of judgment,] a matter of controversy at all?” I will ingenuously tell you: I wanted an immovable point to fix my engine upon, in order to throw down your great Diana, and pull up by the roots the immense trees of Anmtinomian knowledge. And now you have so fully and repeatedly granted me the firm point which I desired, permit me, honoured sir, to throw,myself at your feet, to return you thanks, and tell you that you are the happy prisoner of the truth which I vindicate.
“What do you mean?” What you little expect, dear sir, and what I think you cannot possibly avoid. Yes, whether you will or not, I must serve a friendly warrant, and ‘ young ignorance” arrests you in the name of English logic, to make you publicly subseribe to the anti- Crispian propositions, which your Benedictine monk has rashly traduced. ‘TI will never do it; I am ready to offer myself among the foremost of those true Protestants who could have burned against the doctrine of a second justification by works.” Well then, sir, you shall go, not to the stake near Baliol college, but to “the ground and pillar of truth:”” and that you may not make a needless resistance, I humbly presume to bind you before all the candid and judicious Calvinists in England, with the following necessary consequences of a capital doctrine, which, you tell us, “‘ was never denied, either by Mr. Shirley, or yourself, or any Calvinist you ever heard of.”
If we are * justified by works, i. e. by the evidence of works, both here and at the day of judgment,” it follows, (1.) That Mr. Wesley’s doctrine, with respect to man’s faithfulness in good works, is true; and that if a man (Judas for instance) is not “ faithful in the unrighteous mammon, God will not give him the true riches” of glory. Though he should once have had faith enough to “ leave all and follow Christ, his shipwrecked faith,” sunk by bad works, “ will profit him nothing.” He shall as surely be condemned by the evidence of his unfaithfulness, as ever a highwayman was condemned upon the fullest evidence that he had robbed upon the highway.
- The second proposition of the Minutes also stands now upon an immovable basis. ‘“ Every believer, till he comes to glory, works for as well as from life,” since his works will appear as witnesses for or against him at the day of judgment, and life or death will be the certain consequence of their deposition.
- The third proposition of the Minutes now shines like the meridian sun after an eclipse. Nothing is more false than the maxim, That a man is to do nothing in order to justification, either at conversion or in the last day. For the work of faith undoubtedly takes place in the day of conversion, agreeably to those words of St. Paul, ** We have believed rHaT we might be justified.” And, if even Calvinists grant,
that a sinner is “ justified by the evidence of works, both here and at the day of judgment,” it is ndubitable that he must provide that evidence as there is opportunity; and that if even an apostle provides it not, he shall, notwithstanding his election, increase tle number of those practical Antinomians, whose condemnation I have described in the Second Check. Hence appears: also the error couched under the unguarded proposition which you advance, (p. 12.) “In the act of justification, we affirm good works have no place:” for the good work of faith has the important place of an instrument, when we are justified at our conversion; and the good work of love will have the place of the chief witness, by whose deposition we shall be justified in the great day.
You indeed produce the words of our Church:—*“ The thief did believe only, and the merciful God justified him;” but they make against you, for they intimate that the work of faith was previous to _ his justification. And that he was not saved without works, strictly speaking, although he was saved without the merit of works, I prove by your quotation from Bishop Cowper, Justifying faith, whereby we are saved, cannot be without works; and by these words of St. James and the Rey. Mr. Madan, adapted to the present case: Could “ faith save him? i. e. such a faith as hath not works; as is not productive of the fruits of the Spirit in the heart and life? Is this saving faith? Certainly not.” When our Church says, that he went to heaven without works, she means without the outward works which Pharisees trust to, such as receiving the sacraments, going to the temple, and giving alms; or she grossly contradicts St. James, Bishop Cowper, Mr. Madan, and herself. Therefore, notwithstanding all you have advanced, even the penitent thief’s experience, who, as our Church says, should have lost his salvation, and consequently his justification and election, if he had lived and not regarded the works of faith, is “a formidable rampart” for, not against, St. James’ undefiled religion. Again: Ss When, in the review of the whole affair, Mr. Wesley says, that “he who now believes in Christ with a loving, obedient heart, is now accepted of God,” what does he say more than you, and your favourite bishop, who tells us, (p. 12,) “ That justifying faith, whereby we are saved, cannot be without good works; for faith worketh by love?” Does it not evidently follow, from your own, as well as Mr. Wesley’s position, that while the incestuous Corinthian defiled his father’s bed, his living, justifying faith had degenerated into a dead, devilish faith? agreeably to that evangelically-legal proposition of Mr. Madan, “If my faith does not produce the proper fruits, it is no better than the devil’s faith:” whence it necessarily follows, that the devil’s faith is justifying, or that the Corinthian backslider was condemned; and con- ' sequently, that Calvinism and Antinomianism, the grand pillars of defiled religion, are two broken reeds.
- It is now an indubitable truth, that a sincere heathen, who never heard the name of Christ, and nevertheless “ feareth God and worketh righteousness, according to his light, is accepted of him:” for, if he perseveres, he will be justified in the last day by the evidence of his works of righteousness ; and he is now justified by the instrumentality
of his faith in the light of his dispensation; for this light, when we receive it by faith, if we may believe those excellent mystics,* St. John and St. Paul, is “ Christ in us, the hope of glory,” John i, 5, 9; Col. i, 27; Eph. iii, 27, and v, 14.
- Nor can you now justly refuse to clear Mr. Wesley of the charge of heresy, because he says, Salvation is not by the merit of works, but by works as a condition: for in the present case where is the difference between the word evidence, which you use, with Dr. Guise, Mr. Wesley, and me; and the word condition, which Mr. Wesley uses, and our Church, and most of the Puritan divines? An example will enforce my appeal to your candour: You sit upon the bench as a magistrate, and a prisoner stands at the bar: you say to him, * You are charged with calumny, forgery, and gross perversions ; but you shall be acquitted, on condition that some of your reputable neighbours give you a good character.” A lawyer checks you for using the treasonable word condition, insisting you must say, that the prisoner shall be acquitted or condemned, according to the evidence which his creditable neighbours will give of his good behaviour. You turn to the bar, and say, ‘“‘ Prisoner, did you understand me?” “ Yes, sir,” replies he, “as well as the gentleman who stops your honour.” That is enough,” say you, “Jet us not dispute about words; I am persuaded the court understands we all mean that the acquittal or condemnation of the prisoner will entirely turn upon the deposition of proper witnesses.”
- With regard to the word merit I hope our controversy is at an end: for Mr. Wesley and I, or to speak your own language, old Mordecai and young Ignorance, freely grant what Bishop Hopkins and you assert, (Review, p. 42,) namely, that ‘in all proper merit there must be an equivalence, or at least a proportion of worth between the work and the reward ; and that the obedience we perform cannot be said, without a grand impropriety, to merit any reward from God.” But you must also grant us, that if our Lord, speaking after the manner of men, by
- The word mysticism, like the word enthusiasm, may be used in a good or bad sense. I am no more ashamed of the true mystics, i. e. those who fathom the deep mysteries of inward religion, than of the true enthusiasts, those who are really inspired by the grace and love of God. When I said that Solomon was the great Jewish mystic, I took the word mystic in a good sense; if all are mysties who preach Christ inus, and Christ the Light of the world, (as you intimate in your Five Letters,) I affirm, that St. Paul and St. John are two of the greatest mystics in the world. And when I intimated, that Solomon’s Song is a mystical book, and that the Rev. Mr. Romaine has given a mystical, and in general edifying explanation of the one hundred and seventh Psalm; I no more insulted those good men than our Church reflects upon our Lord, when she says, that ‘“ matrimony represents to us the mystical union between Christ and his Church.” If Mr. Wesley has spoken against mysticism, it is undoubtedly against that which is wild and unscriptural; for he has shown us his approbation of rational and Scriptural mysticism, by publishing very edifying extracts from the works of the great
_ German and English mystics, Kempis and Mr. Law. Permit me to recommend to you what Mr. Hartley, a clergyman whom you have quoted with honour, has written in defence of the mystics; and to remind you, that, abroad, those who go a little deeper into inward Christianity than the generality of their neighbours, are called pietists, or mystics, as commonly as they are called Methodists in England. On the preceding accounts I hope, that when Mr. Wesley, or Mr. Shirley, shall again condemn mysticism, they will particularly observe that it is only unscriptural and irrational mysticism which they explode — a grand catechresis,* a very condescending impropriety, frequently uses the word meriting, or deserving, we may without heresy use it after him.
Should you ask me how I can prove that our Lord ever used it, I reply, that if he used again and again words answering to it, as face answers to face in a glass, itis just as if he had used the English word merit, or Mr. Wesley’s Latin word meritum: and to prove that he did so I appeal to the first Greek lexicon you will meet with. I suppose it is that of Schrevelius, because it is the most common all Europe over. Look for mereor, (to merit or deserve,) and you will find that the correspondent Greek is picdov gepew, literally to carry a reward, and agiog cies, to be worthy; Agia answers to meritum, merit; and afiws to merito, deservedly, or according to one’s merit. . To prove, therefore, that our Lord did not scruple to use the word merit in an improper sense, I need only prove that he did not scruple applying the words pucSo¢g and agg to man. Take some instances of both:—
- Matt. xx, 8,“ Give them tov pioSov, their hire, or reward.” And again Matt. ver. 12, “ Your reward (yicSo¢) is great in heaven,” &c. Hence the apostle calls God (ycSarodorns) the Rewarder ; and Moses is said “to look to (uioSamodociav) the recompense of reward,” Heb. xi, 6, 26. And the word wicSanodocia, the bestowing of a reward, as much answers to the word pucSopopia} the carrying of a reward, or merit, as the relative words which necessarily suppose one another. He, therefore, that uses the former without scruple, makes himself quite ridiculous before unprejudiced people if he scruples using the latter ; much more if he thinks the doing it is a dreadful heresy.
- As for the other word (aZioc) meriting, deserving, or worthy, it 18 as Scriptural as any word in the Bible. You find it used both in a proper and in an improper sense in the following scriptures :—(1.) In a PROPER sense: “ The labourer is worthy of, or merits, his hire, Luke x, 7. Worthy, or deserving, stripes, Luke xii, 48. Worthy of, or meriting death, Acts xxi, 11. They have shed the blood of thy saints, and thou hast given them blood to drink, for they are worthy :” that is, they merit, they deserve it, Rev. xvi, 6. (2.) In an mmpropeR sense, which you represent as heretical: “They shall walk with me in white, for they are worthy, Rev. iii, 4. Inquire who zs worthy, Matt. x, 11. Worthy of me, Matt. x, 37. They that were bidden were not worthy, Matt. xxii, 8. Worthy to escape these things, Luke xxi, 36. Worthy to obtain that world,” Luke xx, 35, &c, &c.
In all these passages the original word is agss, worthy, meriting, or deserving. Bishop Cowper, therefore, whom you quote in your Five Letters, p. 26, spoke with uncommon rashness when he said, “‘ No man led by the Spirit of Jesus, did ever use this word of merit, [i. e. asog ewas| as applying to man. It is the proud speech of antichrist. Search the Scriptures, and ye shall see that none of all those who speak by Divine inspiration did ever use it: yea, the godly fathers always abhorred it.” What! the sacred writers ‘never used the word oso ewor!” The godly fathers always abhorred” an expression which the
- A figure of speech, which consists in using a word in an improper sense; as when unfaithful ministers are called ‘dogs that cannot bark.”
Holy Ghost so frequently makes use of! Christ himself “ spoke by the proud spirit of antichrist!” When I see such camels obtruded upon the Church, and swallowed down by thousands as glib truth, I am cut to the heart, and, in a pang of sorrow and shame, groan, “ From such divinity, good Lord, deliver me, my worthy opponent, and all real Protestants!”
To this Mr. Rowland Hill answers beforehand, in his Friendly Remarks, p. 28. This is “a bad criticism upon the word aig, which more properly means meet or fit.”” Now, sir, to your bare assertion I oppose, (1.) All the Greek lexicons. (2.) The testimony of Beza, Calvin’s successor, who speaking of the word a£ig, says, It is properly used of that which is of equal weight and importance. (3.) The testimony of Leigh, another learned Calvinist, who, in his Critica Sacra, says, “afios has its name from ayew, a trahendo: Que preponderant lancem attrahunt; and is a metaphor taken from balances, when one scale doth counterpoise another.” And speaking of agsw, a word derived from a£ios, he adds, “It signifieth when either reward or punishment is given according to the proportion of merit.” And this he proves, by 1 Tim. v, 17, “ Let the elders that rule well be counted worthy of double honour: for the Scripture says, The labo p is worthy of his reward.”
When I see the learned Calvinists forced to grant all we contend for, I wish that no Protestant may any longer expose his prejudice, in denying what is absolutely undeniable, viz. That Christ and his apostles assert, some men merit, or are worthy of rewards. ‘Taking care, therefore, never to fix to those Scriptural words the idea of proper worthiness,.or merit of condignity, let us no longer fight against Christ, by saying, they are in no sense worthy, whom Christ himself makes, accounts, and calls wortuHy; yea, whom he gloriously rewards as such.
- As for this modest proposition of the Minutes, “ It is a doubt if God justifies any one that never did fear him, and work righteousness,” it stands now established by your concessions, not as matter of doubt, but as a matter of fact, if we speak of justification in the hour of conversion, or in the day of judgment. For, with respect to the former, you justly observe, (p. 12,) that “the faith whereby we are saved,” and consequently justified, ‘ cannot be without good works.” And with regard to the latter, you say, (p. 149,) ‘* What need is there of making our justification, by the evidence of works in the day of judg ment, a matter of controversy at all? We are quite agreed that a sinner is declaratively justified by works.”? Now, honoured sir, if he is justified by works, it is undoubtedly by works of righteousness; unless it could be proved that he may be justified by works of unrighteousness, by adultery and murder.
- It is likewise evident from your own concessions, that “ talking of a justified, or a sanctified state,” without paying a due regard to good works, tends to mislead men, and actually misleads thousands. If Judas, for instance, when he neglected good works, which are the mark of our first, and the instrument of our second justification, trusted to what was done in the moment, in which he was effectually called to leave all, and follow Jesus, he grossly deceived himself: or if he
depended upon imputed righteousness, when he neglected personal holiness, he built upon the loosest sand.
The seasonableness of Mr. Wesley’s caution in this respect will strike you, honoured sir, if you cast your eyes upon the numbers of fallen believers, who once, like obedient Judas, left all to follow Christ; but having resumed their besetting sin, like the apostolic traitor, now sell their Saviour and election, perhaps for a less valuable consideration than he did. However, they were once in a justified and sanctified state, and Mr. Hill tells them, that “in the act of justification good wo1ks have no place,” and insinuates, that adulterers and murderers may be in the winter season of a sanctified state; therefore they reasonably conclude, that they are still justified and sanctified. Thus they live, and if God does not send them an honest Nathan, or if when he comes they stop their ears, and cry out, Heresy, thus hke Judas they will die.
With respect to the last clause of the Minutes, you must acknowledge, “that we are every moment pleasing or displeasing to God, according to the whole of our inward tempers and outward behaviour:” or, to clothe Mr. Wesley’s doctrine in words in which you agree with me, you must confess, that, “‘as we may die every hour, and every moment, we are liable to be every hour and every moment Justified, or condemned, by the evidence of our works.”* This is evident, if you consider St. Paul’s words, “‘ Without faith it is impossible to please God;”’ and if you do not recant what you say, (Review, p. 12,) “ Justifying faith [the faith by which we please God] cannot be without good works.” You must therefore prove that adultery, treachery, and murder, are good works, and by that means openly plead for Belial, Baal, and Beelzebub; or you must grant, that when David committed those crimes he had not justifying faith, and consequently did not please God. And the moment you grant this, you set your seal to the last proposition of the Minutes, which you esteem most contrary, and I entirely agreeable, to sound doctrine.
Having thus, by the help of your own concessions, once more removed the rock of offence, under which you try to crush the seasonable rampart of St. James’ undefiled religion, which we call the Minutes, I leave you to consider how much Mr. Wesley has been misunderstood, and how much the truth of the Gospel has been set at naught.
I am, honoured and dear sir, yours, &c,
J. FLETCHER. '
LETTER VI. To Richard Hill, Esq.
Hon. anp Dear Sir,—While my engine, common sense, stands yet firm upon the point of our justification by the evidence of works, which you have so fully granted me, permit me to level it a moment
- The reader is once more desired to remember, that by works we understand, not only the works of the tongue and hands, i. e. words and actions; but also, and gtk se works of the mind and heart, that is, thoughts, desires, and tempers
at the basis of the main pillars which support Antinomianism and Calvinism.
- If righteous Lot had died when he repeated the crimes of drunkenness and incest, his justification would have been turned into con- demnation, according to St. Paul’s plain rule, If thou be a breaker of the law, thy circumeision is made uncireumcision: for neither the holy God, nor any virtuous man, can possibly justify a sinner upon the evidence of drunkenness and incest.
- If old Solomon, doating upon heathenish young women, and led away by them into abominable idolatries, had died before he was brought again to repentance, he could never have seen the kingdom. of God. He should have perished in his sin, unless Geneva logic can make it appear, in direct opposition to the word of God, that the impenitent shall not perish, and that zdolaters shall inherit the kingdom of God, Luke xiii, 3; 1 Cor. vi, 9.
- If the incestuous Corinthian had been cut off while he defiled his father’s bed, the justification granted him at his first conversion, far from saving him in the day of judgment, would have aggravated hig condemnation, and caused him to be counted worthy of a much severer punishment than if he never had known the way of righteousness,—never been justified ; unless you can prove that Christ would have acquitted him upon the horrid evidence of apostasy and incest, which appears to me as difficult a task as to prove that Christ and Belial are one and the same filthy god..
- If David and Bathsheba had been run through by Uriah, ‘as Zimri and Cosbi were by Phinehas ; and if they had died in their flagrant wickedness, no previous justification, no Calyinian imputation of righteousness, would have secured their justification in the last day. For, upon the evidence of adultery and premeditated murder, they would infallibly have been condemned; according to those awful words of our Lord, I come quickly to give EVERY MAN, [here is no exception for the “ pleasant children,” ] according as u1s work shall be, not according as my work has been. Blessed are they that do his commandments, that they may enter in through the gates into the city; for without are dogs, WHOREMONGERS, and MURDERERS, Rey. xxii, 12, &e.
Should you say, honoured sir, It is provided in the decree of absolute election that adulterers, who once walked with God, shall not die till they have repented: (1.) I demand proof that there ever was such a decree. In the second Psalm, indeed, I read about God’s decree respecting Christ and mankind; but it is the very reverse of Calvin’s decree, for it implies general redemption and conditional election. J will declare the decree. Thou art my son. I will give thee the wEa- THEN for thine inheritance, and the urTERMosT parts of the earth for — thy possession. Kiss the son, lest he be angry, and ye perish from the way. a This evasion is founded upon a most absurd supposition, which sews pillows to the arms of backsliders and apostates, by promising them immortality if they persevere in sin. But setting aside the absurdity of supposing that old Solomon, for example, might have kept himself alive till now by assiduously worshipping Ashtaroth; or, which is the same, that he might have put off death by putting off repentance, because he could not die till he had repented: I ask, Where is this strange Gospel written? Certainly not in the Old Testament; for God asks there with indignation, “ When the righteous turneth away from his righteousness, and committeth iniquity, sHaLL HE Live?” No: “in his sin that he has sinned sHALL HE DIE,” Ezek. xviii, 24. Much less in the New, where Christ protests, that he will spue lukewarm believers out of his mouth, and that every branch in him which bears not fruit, shall be taken away or cut off. An awful threatening this, which was executed even upon one of the twelve apostles! For our Lord himself says, Those that thou Gavest me I have kept, and none of THEM is lost but Judas, who fell finally, since he died in the very act of self murder, and is particularly called the son of perdition.
But granting you, that lest Lot, David, and Solomon should be condemned by works in the day of judgment, they were to be immortal till they repented and did their first works; this very supposition indicates, that till they repented they were sons of perdition, according to that solemn declaration of truth manifest in the flesh, Except ye repent, ye shall all perish.
As if you were aware of this difficulty, (p. 149,) you have recourse to a noted distinction in Geneva logic, by which you hope to secure your favourite doctrine, as well as fond Rachel once secured her favourite teraphim. You say, “ that though a sinner [ David, for instance, or Solomon] be justified in the sight of God by Christ alone, he is declaratively justified by works both here and at the day of judgment.”
Now, honoured sir, this necessarily implies, that though David in Uriah’s bed, and Solomon at the shrine of Ashtaroth, are justified in the sight of God by Christ’s chastity and piety imputed to them; yet, before men, and before the Judge of quick and dead, they are justified by the evidence of their own chastity and piety. This distinction, one of the main supports of Calvinism, is big with absurdities; for if it be just, it follows,
- That while God says of Solomon, worshipping the goddess of the Zidonians, he is still a true believer, “he is justified from all things ;” Christ says, By his fruit ye shall know him ; he is an impenitent, unjustified idolater; and St. James, siding with his Master, says roundly, that Solomon’s faith being now without works is a dead, unjustifying faith ; by which, as well as by his bad works, he is condemned already. Now, sir, it remains that you should give up Antinomian Calvinism, or tell us who is grossly mistaken, God or Christ. For, upon your scheme, God says of an impenitent idolater, who once believed in him, “ He is fully justified by the perfect law of liberty.” And Christ says, “ TIe is fully condemned by the same law!” And reason dictates, that both parts of a full contradiction cannot be true.
Do not say, honoured sir, that, upon the Calvinian plan, the Father and the Son never contradict one another in the matter of a sinner’s justification; for if the Father justifies by the imputation of an external righteousness, which constitutes a sinner righteous while he commits all sorts of crimes; and if the Son, on the other hand, condemns a sinner for his words, much more for the commission of adultery, idolatry, and murder; their sentence must be as frequently different as a believer acts or speaks, contrary to the law of liberty. For Christ being the same yesterday, to-day, and for ever, cannot justify: he must condemn now, as well as in the day of judeme every man who now acts or speaks wickedly.
Should you attempt to account for the Father’ s imaginary justification of an impenitent idolater, by bringing in Calvin’s decrees, and saying that God reckoned Solomon a converted man at the shrine of Ashtaroth, because he had absolutely decreed to give him restoring grace; I reply, supposing such decrees are not imaginary, is it not absurd to say, God reckons that cold is heat, and confounds January with July, because he has decreed that summer shall follow winter? Therefore, which way soever you turn, absurdities or impieties stare you in the face.
- The unreasonableness of Calvinism will appear to you more glaringly still, if you suppose for a moment that David died in Uriah’s bed. For then, according to Dr. Crisp’s justification by the imputation of Christ’s chastity, he must have gone straight to heaven; and, according to our Lord’s condemnation, by the evidence of personal adultery, he must have gone straight to hell. Thus, by the help of Geneva logic, so sure as the royal adulterer might have died before Nathan stirred him up to repentance, I can demonstrate, that David might have been saved and damned, in heaven and in hell, at the same
time !
- Your distinction insinuates, that there will be two days of judgment; one to try us secretly before God, by imputed sin and imputed righteousness ; and the other to try us publicly before men and angels, by personal sin and personal righteousness. A new doctrine this, which every Christian is bound to reject, not only because the Scripture is silent about it, but because it fixes a shocking duplicity of con- duct upon God; for it represents him, first, as absolutely saving or damning the children of men, according to his own capricious imputation of Christ’s righteousness, or of Adam’s sin; and then as being desirous to make a show of justice before men and angels, by pretending to justify or condemn people “ according to their works,” when in fact he has already justified or condemned them without the least respect to their works ; for, say: Bishop Cowper and Mr. Hill, “ In the act of justification, good works have no place;” and, indeed, how should they, if free grace and free wrath have unalterably cast the lot of all, before the foundation of the world ?—or, in other terms, if finished salvation and finished damnation have the stamp of God, as well as that of Calvin?
- According to your imaginary distinction, Christ, as King of saints, frequently condemns for inherent wickedness, those whom he justifies, as a Priest, by imputed righteousness ; and so, to the disgrace of his wisdom, he publicly recants, as a Judge, the sentence of complete justification, which he privately passes as a God. Permit me, honoured sir, to enforce this observation by the example of Judas, or any other apostate. I hope nobody will charge me with blasphemy, for saying that our Lord called Judas with the same sincerity with which he called his other disciples. Heaven forbid that any Christian should suppose the Lamb of God called Iscariot to get him into the pit of perdition, as the fowler does an unhappy bird which he wants to get
into a decoy. Judas readily answered the call, and undoubtedly believed in Christ as well as the rest of the apostles; for St. John says, “ This beginning of miracles did Jesus in Cana of Galilee, and manifested forth his glory, and his disciples [of whom Judas was one] believed in him.” His faith was true so far as it went; for he was one of “the little flock to whom it was God’s good pleasure to give the kingdom,” Luke xii, 32. Our Lord pronounced him “ blessed,” with the rest of his disciples, Matt. xiii, 16, and conditionally promised him one of the twelve apostolic crowns in his glory, Matt. xix, 28.
If you say, that “he was always a traitor anda hypocrite,” you run into endless difficulties; for, (1.) You make Christ countenance, by his example, all bishops, who knowingly ordain wicked men—all patrons, who give them livings—and all kings, who prefer ungodly men to high dignities in the Church. (2.) You suppose that Christ, who would not receive an occasional testimony from an eyil spirit, not only sent a devil to preach and baptize in his name, but at his return encouraged him in his horrid dissimulation, by bidding him “ rejoice that his name was written in heaven.” (3.) You believe, “ that the faithful and true Witness,” in whose mouth no guile was ever found, gave this absurd, hypocritical charge to a goat, an arch hypocrite, a devil: “ Behold, I send you forth as sheep in the midst of wolves; but fear not, the hairs of your head are all numbered. A sparrow shall not fall to the ground without your Father, and ye are of more value than many sparrows. Do not premeditate, it shall be given you what you shall speak: for it is not you.that speak, but the Spirit of your Father which speaketh in you.”
When our Lord spoke thus to Judas, he was a sheep, i.e. “ he heard Christ’s voice, and followed him.” But, alas! he was afterward taken by the bright shining of silver and gold, as David was by the striking beauty of Uriah’s wife. And when he had admitted the base temptation, our Lord, with the honesty of a Master, and tenderness of a Saviour, said, Have not I chosen you twelve, and one of you isa devil?” He has let the tempter into his heart. This severe, though indirect reproof, reclaimed Judas for a time; as a similar rebuke checked Peter on another occasion. Nor was it, probably, till near the end of our Lord’s ministry that he began to be “ unfaithful in the mammon of unrighteousness:” and even then Christ kindly warned, without exposing him.
Some, indeed, think that our Lord was partial to Peter; but I do not see it: for with equal love and faithfulness he warned all his disciples of their approaching fall, and mentioned the peculiar circum- stances of Judas’ and Peter’s apostasy. ‘Aye, but he prayed for Peter that his faith might not fail.” And is this a proof that he never prayed for Judas? That he always excepted him, when he prayed for his disciples, and that he would have excepted him, if he had been alive when he interceded for all his murderers? ‘* However, he looked at Peter, te cover him with a penitential shame.” Nay he did more than this for Judas; for he pointed at him, first indirectly, and then directly, to bring him to a sense of his crime. But, supposing our Lord had not at all endeavoured to stop him in his dreadful career, would this have been a proof of his reprobating partiality? Is it not said, that “the Lord weigheth the spirits?” As such, did he not see that Judas offended of malicious wickedness and calm deliberation; and that Peter would offend merely through fear and surprise? Supposing, therefore, he had made a difference between them, would it be right to account for it by Calvinian election and reprobation, when the difference might so naturally be accounted for from the different state of their hearts, and nature of their falls? Was it not highly agreeable to the notions we have of justice, and the declarations we read in the Scripture, that our Lord should reprobate, or give up Judas, when he saw him immovably fixed in his apostasy, and found that the last hour of his day of grace was now expired?
From all these circumstances, I hope I may conclude, that Judas was not always a hypocrite; that he may be properly ranked among apostates, that is, among those who truly fall from God, and therefore were once truly in him; and that our Lord spoke no untruth, when he called the Spirit of God the Spirit of Judas’ Father, without making any difference between him and the other disciples.
If you ask, How he fell? I reply, That, overlooking an important part of our Lord’s pastoral charge to him, “* He that endureth unto the end the same shall be saved,” he dallied with worldly temptations till the evil spirit, which was gone out of him, entered in again, with seven other spirits more wicked than himself, and took possession of his heart, which was once swept from reigning sin, and garnished with the graces which adorn the Christian in his infant state. Thus, like Hymeneus, Philetus, Demas, and other apostates, “ by putting away a good conscience, concerning faith he made shipwreck,” and evidenced the truth of God’s declaration: ‘‘ When the righteous turneth away from his righteousness, all his righteousness that he hath done shall not be mentioned: in his sin that he hath sinned he shall die.”
Nay, Judas kept his Master’s money, and was a thief; therefore he was always a hypocrite, an absolute reprobate.”
To show the weakness of this objection, I need only retort it thus: David set his heart upon his neighbour’s wife, as Judas did upon his Master’s money, and like him betrayed innocent blood; therefore he was always a hypocrite, an absolute reprobate. If the inference is just in one case, it is undoubtedly so in the other. * “ But David repented, and did his first works.”.
I thank my objector for this important concession. Did Judas perish? It was then because he did not do his first works, though he repented. And is David saved? It is because he not only repented, but did also his first works; or, to use your own expressions, because he recovered “ justifying faith, which cannot be without good works.” Thus, when he had recovered justifying faith before God, he could again be justified by the evidence of works, both before his fellow mortals, and that God who “ judges the world in righteousness,” and who sentences every man according to his own works, and not merely according to works done by another near 6000 or 1800 years before they were born. Thus the royal adulterer, who died a justified, chaste penitent, can, through the merits of Christ, stand before the throne in a better and more substantial righteousness than the fantastic robe in which you imagine he was clothed, when his eyes were full of adultery, and his hands full of blood: an airy, loose, flimsy robe this, cut out at Geneva and Dort, not at Jerusalem or Antioch; a wretched contrivance, the chief use of which is to cover the iron-clay feet of the Calvinian Diana, and afford a safe asylum, a decent canopy to “ the pleasant children,” while they debauch their neighbours’ wives, and hypocritically murder them out of the way.
O ye good men, how long will ye inadvertently represent our God, who is glorious in holiness, as the pander of vice? and Christ’s imma culate righteousness as the unseemly cloak of such wickedness as is not so much as named among the Gentiles? “O that salvation, from this evil, were given unto Israel out of Sion!” O that the Lord would deliver his people from this preposterous error! O that the blast of Divine indignation, and the sighs of thousands of good men, lighting at once on the great image, might tear away the loose robe of righteousness which Calvin put upon her in a “ winter season!”” Then could all the world read the mark of the beast and the fiend, which she wears on her naked breast: “Free adultery, free murder, free incest, any length of sin for the pleasant children, the little flock of the elect: free wrath, free vengeance, free damnation for the immense herd of the reprobates!”
But to return to Judas, the first of all Christian apostates: waiving the consideration of his justification in his infancy, I observe, that as he had once true faith, he undoubtedly “believed to righteousness,” and consequently “ it was imputed to him for righteousness.” Now, if this mean that God put upon him a loose robe of righteousness, which for ever screened him from condemnation, and under which he could conceal a bag of stolen money, as easily as: you suppose David hid the ewe lamb which he conveyed away from Uriah’s pasture, it follows, upon your scheme, that “ justification being one single immutable act, in which works have no place,” Judas is still completely justified before God by Calvinian imputation of righteousness; although Christians have hitherto believed works have so important a place in justification, that the apostate is no less condemned before God, than before men and angels, by his avarice and treason.
Let those who can split a hair as easily as an eagle can find her passage between east and west, take the chosen apostle, who did not make his election sure by the works of faith, and let them split him asunder: so shall happy Iscariot, the dear elected child of God, wrapped in imputed righteousness, and carried by everlasting love, infallibly go to heaven without works, in consequence of his Calvinian justification before God; while poor reprobated Judas, for accomplishing God’s decree, shall infallibly go to his own place, in consequence of his condemnation by the evidence of wicked works.
Thus, honoured sir, by fixing my plain engine, common sense, upon the immovable point which you have granted me, i. e. St. James’ justification by works, I hope I have not only removed the rock of offence from off Mr. Wesley’s anti-Crispian propositions, but heaved also your great Diana, and her brother Apollo, (I mean unconditional election and absolute reprobation) from off the basis of orthodoxy, on which you suppose they stand firm as the pillars of heaven. May the God of pure, impartial love, whom they have so long indirectly traduced, as a God of blind dotage to hundreds, and implacable wrath to millions of his creatures, in the very same circumstances.—the God whom those unscriptural doctrines have represented as fond Eli, and grim Apollyon; - may he, I say, arise for his name’s sake, and touch the Geneva colossus with his own omnipotent finger; so shall it in a moment fall from the amazing height of reverence to which Calvin, the Synod of Dort, and Elisha Coles have raised it; and its undeceived votaries shall perceive, they had no more reason to call Geneva impositions “ the doctrines of grace,” than good Aaron and the mistaken Israelites to give the tremendous name of JeHovau to the ridiculous idol, which they had devoutly set up in the absence of legal Moses; so, giving glory to God, they shall confess that the robe of their image, with which some so officiously cover impenitent adulterers and murderers, is no more like the true wedding garment, than the imaginary appearances of armed men in the clouds are like the multitude of the heavenly host.
While you try to defend this robe, and I to tear it off the back of Antinomian Jezebel, let us not neglect ‘ putting off the old man, putting on Christ Jesus, and walking in him” as St. Paul, or with him as Enoch, “arrayed in: fine linen, clean and white, which is the righteousness imparted to the saints, when Christ is formed in their hearts by faith,” and imputed to them so long as they walk, in their measure, ‘as he also walked.” That, notwithstanding our warm controversy, we may “ walk in love” with each other, and all the people of God, is the prayer of, honoured and dear sir, your obedient and devoted servant, in St. James’ Gospel, JouHN FLETCHER.
LETTER VII. To Richard Hill, Esq.
Honovrep anv Dear Sir,—The fourth letter of your Review you produce as “a full and particular answer” to what I have advanced against Dr. Crisp’s scheme of finished salvation, and finished damnation. But to my great surprise, you pass in profound silence over my strongest arguments. Had I beensin your place, I would have paid some regard to my word, printed in capitals in my title page: I would have tried to prove, that, upon the doctor’s scheme, St. Paul might, consistently with wisdom, exhort the Philippians “to work out their [finished] salvation with fear and trembling.” And if I could not have made it appear, that our Lord has finished his work, as an interposing Mediator, a teaching Prophet, and a ruling King; I would either have given up the point, or endeavoured to show, that he has finished it at least as a Priest.
But even this you could not do without setting aside two important parts of his priestly office: for the same Jesus, who offered up himself as the true paschal Lamb, is now exalted at the right hand of God, to bless us as our Melchisedec, and “make intercession for us” as our Aaron, saying daily concerning a multitude of barren fig trees in his vineyard, “ Let them alone this year also, till I shall dig about them ; and if they bear fruit, well: and if not, then after that thou shalt cut them down.” Now if he daily carries on his own personal work of salvation, not only as a Prophet and a King, but also as a Mediator and a Priest, common sense dictates, that ‘his personal work” is no more finished than our own; and that the doctrine of finished salvation is founded upon a heap of palpable mistakes, if by that expression you mean any thing more than a finished atonement.
But, oyerlooking these insurmountable difficulties, you open your “full and particular answer’’ by saying, pp. 62, 63, ‘‘ Finished salvation is a grand fortress, against which all your artillery is played, and at which your heavy bombs of bitter sneer and cutting sarcasm are thrown. Yet this very expression, in its full extent, I undertake to vindicate, and in so doing shall fly to the sword of the Spirit; and the Lord enabling me to wield it aright, I doubt not I shall put to flight the armies of the aliens.” Let us now see how you manage your sword, put us to flight, and establish finished salvation.
I. Page 63, “* When the Lord of glory gave up the ghost, he cried, ‘It is finished.’ And what was finished? Not merely his life, but ‘the work which was given him to do.’ And what was this work, but the salvation of his people? One would have imagined, that the Lord’s own use of this expression might have silenced every cavil.”
The Lord’s own use of this contested expression, “ finished salvation!” Pray, dear sir, where does he use it? Certainly not in the two passages you quote, ‘J have finished the work thou gavest me to do,” previously to my entering on my passion; and “ It is finished;” that is, all the prophecies relative to what I was to do, teach, and suffer before my death, are accomplished. ‘These scriptures do not in the least refer to the work of salvation on our part; nor do they even take in the most important branches of salvation’s work on Christ’s part. To assert it, is to take a bold stride into Socinianism, and maintain, it was not needful to our salvation that Christ should die, and rise again. For when he said, “I have finished the work thou gavest me to do,” he was not yet entered upon his passion: nor had he died for our sins, much less was he yet risen for our justification, when he said upon the cross, “It is finished.” To suppose, then, that salvation’s work on Christ’s part was finished, not only before his resurrection, but also before his death, is to set aside some of his most important works, in direct opposition to the Scriptures, which testify, that “he died, the just for the unjust;” and affirm, that “if he is not raised, our faith is vain, we are yet in our sins.” Thus, sir, you have so unhappily begun to * wield your sword,” as to cut down, at the first stroke, the two grand articles of the Christian faith—the death and resurreciion of Jesus Christ. ’ II. Page 33. To mend the matter, you have recourse to the mysterious doctrine of the decrees; and because “all events are present unto God, and were so from eternity to eternity,” you affirm that “ the glorification of the elect is as much finished as their predestination.” By the same rule of Geneva logic, I may say, that because God has decreed the world shall melt with fervent heat, the general conflagration is as much finished as the deluge. Were ever more strange asser- tions obtruded upon mankind?
If this illustration does not convince you of your mistake, I turn the tables, and make your blood run cold with the dreadful counterpart of your own proposition. The damnation of the non-elect “born or unborn,” is as much finished as their predestination. And are these “ the good tidings of great joy which shall be to all people?” and is this the comfortable Gospel of free grace, which we are “to preach to every creature?” Alas, my dear sir, you wield your sword so unskilfully, as absolutely to cut down all hopes and possibility of mercy for millions of your fellow creatures; even for all the poor reprobates on the left side of the ship, who, “from eternity to eternity were irresistibly enclosed in the net of finished damnation!”
Ili. Page 63. To support your unscriptural assertion, you produce Rom. viii, 29, ‘“‘ Whom he did predestinate, them he called: and whom he called, them he also justified; and whom he justified, them he also glorified.” Indeed, sir, the apostle no more meant to insinuate by these words, that David was justified and glorified when he wallowed in the filth of adultery and murder, than that, Judas was condemned and damned when he left all to follow Christ. He only lays before us an account of the method which God follows in the eternal salvation of obedient, persevering believers; who are the persons that, as such, he predestinated to life, “ according to his foreknowledge, and the counsel of his holy will.” These “he called,” but not these alone. When they made their calling sure, by believing in the light of their dispensation, these “ he also justified.” And when they made their justifica- tion sure, by “‘adding to their faith virtue,” &c, these “he also glorified;” for the souls of departed saints are actually glorified in Abraham’s bosom; and living saints are not only called and justified, but also in part glorified; for, by “the Spirit of glory and of God, which rests upon them, they are changed into the Divine image from glory to glory;” yea, they are already “all glorious within.”
How much more reasonable and Scriptural is this sense of the apostle’s words than that which you fix upon them, by which you would make us believe, that, on the one hand, Solomon’s salvation (including his justification and glorification) was finished, “in the full extent of the expression,” when he worshipped the abomination of the Zidonians,. and gloried in his shame: while, on the other hand, Demas’ damnation was finished when he was St. Paul’s zealous “ companion in the kingdom and patience of Jesus Christ!” O sir, have you not here also inadvertently used the “ sword of the Spirit,” to oppose the “ mind of the Spirit,” and make way for barefaced Antinomianism? You proceed: IV. Page 63. “The same apostle, in his Epistle to the Ephesians, speaking to believers, addresses them as already (virtually) ‘ seated in heavenly places in Christ Jesus.’”” Hence you infer, that their salvation was.finished, ‘in the full extent of the expression.” But your conclusion is not just; for the apostle, instead of supposing their salvation finished, exhorts them “ not to steal, not to be drunk with wine, and not to give place to the devil,” by fornication, uncleanness, filthiness, or covetousness; “for this ye know,” adds he, ‘that no unclean person, &c, hath any inheritance in the kingdom of Christ;” so far is he from being “already virtually seated in heavenly places in Christ Jesus.”
What need is there of “ darkening counsel by a word without knowledge?” By the dark word “virtually ’” While the Ephesians kept the faith, did they not “set their affections on things above?” Were not their hearts in heaven with Christ agreeably to our Lord’s doctrine, ‘Where your treasure is, there will your heart be also?” And by a lively faith, which is “ the substance of things hoped for,” did they not already share the glory of their exalted Head? Will you still endeavour to persuade the world, that when David defiled his neighbour’s bed, he was * seated in heavenly places in Christ?” Is it not evident that these, and the like expressions of St. Paul, must not be understood of idle Antinomian speculations; but of such a real change as our Church mentions in her collect for Ascension day? “Grant, that as Christ ascended into the heavens, so we may also in heart and mind thither ascend, and continually dwell.”” Such powerful exertions of faith, hope, and love, as are described in the 77th hymn of the Rev. Mr. Madan’s collection 2 By faith we are come To our permanent home; By hope we the rapture improve: By love we still rise, And look down on the skies— For the heaven of heaven is love!
But this is not all: if the elect, whether they be drunk or sober, chaste or unclean, “are already virtually seated in heavenly places in Christ,” according to the doctrine of finished salvation; are not poor reprobates, whether they pray or curse, repent or sin, already virtually seated in hellish places in the devil, according to the doctrine of finished damnation? O sir, when you use the sword of the Spirit to storm the New Jerusalem, and cut the way through law and Gospel before an adulterer in flagrante delicto, that he may virtually [that is, I fear, comfortably and securely | “ sit in heavenly places in Christ,” do you not dreadfully prostitute God’s holy word? Inadvertently fight the battle of the rankest Antinomians, and secure the foundation of Mr. Sandiman’s, as well as Dr. Crisp’s increasing errors?’ But you have an excuse ready:-— VY. Page 63. “ Christ has purchased the Spirit, to work mortification of sin, &c, in the hearts of his children: and in this respect their sanctification is really as much finished as their justification.” I reply, (1.) If their justification by works is not finished before the day of judgment, as our Lord informs us, Matt. xii, 37, your observation proves just nothing. (2.) The Scriptures, in direct opposition to your scheme, declare, that the Spirit strives with, and consequently was purchased for all; those who “ quench” it, and “sin against the Holy Ghost,” not excepted. Therefore, neither the sanctification nor salvation of sinners is absolutely secured by the purchase you mention. If it were, all the world would be saved. But, alas! many “deny the Lord that bought them,” and by “ doing despite to the Spirit of grace” purchased for them, “ bring upon themselves swift destruction,” instead of finished salvation. Here, then, the sword which you wield flies again to pieces, by clashing with the real sword of the Spirit, brandished by St. Peter and St. Paul.
VI. Page 64. You bring in “the immutability of God’s counsel confirmed by an oath,” and add, “The will and testament is signed, sealed, and properly attested. The whole affair is finished. There remains nothing to do but to take possession.” I thank you, dear sir, for this concession; something then “remains to do:” we must, at least, “‘ take possession;” and if we neglect doing it, farewell finished salvation. We shall as much fall short of the heavenly, as the Israelites, who perished in the wilderness, because they refused to take possession, fell short of the earthly Canaan.
Again: we grant that God’s “will and testament is finished and sealed by Christ’s most precious blood:” and that “the everlasting covenant is ordered in all things, and sure.” But if part of that will and covenant runs thus: “ Ye are saved by grace through faith. You are kept by the power of God through faith. If ye continue in the faith. Faith without works is dead. Wherefore work out your own salvation with fear and trembling. For him that sinneth I will blot out of my book. If ye walk contrary to me, I will walk contrary to you. I will cut my staff, beauty, asunder, that I may break my covenant which I have made with all the people, Zech. xi, 10. And ye shall know my breach of promise, Num. xiy, 34. I will therefore put you in remembrance, though ye once knew this, how that the Lord, having saved the people out of the land of Egypt, afterward destroyed them that believed not; although through faith they kept the passoyer, and the sprinkiing of blood, lest the destroyer should touch them. And did all drink the same spiritual drink, (for they drank of that spiritual rock that followed them; and that rock was Christ.) Now all these things happened to them for examples: and they are written for our admonition. Wherefore let him that thinketh he standeth take heed lest he fall.” If part of God’s will and covenant, I say, runs thus, is it not absurd to suppose, that any man’s salvation is finished while he not only does not comply with the gracious terms of God’s “ sure covenant,” but notoriously incurs the dreadful threatenings recorded in his unalterable “ will and testament?” Here, then, instead of * turning to flight the armies of the aliens,” you have given us weapons to beat you out of the field. But you soon come back again to say,— VII. Page 64. “ Certain it is, that the salvation of every soul given by the Father to the Son, in the eternal covenant of redemption, is as firmly secured as if those souls were already in glory.” ‘The certainty which you speak of, exists only in your own imagination. Judas was given by the Father to the Son; and yet Judas is lost. If the salvation of some people “was as firmly secured from the beginning as if they had already been in glory,” all the Gospel ministers who have addressed them at any time as children of wrath, have been preachers of lies, and the Holy Spirit witnesses to an untruth, when he testifies to the unregenerate elect that they are in danger of hell. But this is not all: upon your dangerous scheme, the foundations are thrown down; man is no more in a state of trial; the day of judgment will be a mere farce; and the Scriptures are a farrago of the most absurd cautions, and the most scandalous lies: for they perpetually speak to believers as to persons in danger of “ falling,” and “ being cut off,” if they do not “ walk circumspectly;” and they assert that some “ perish for whom Christ died;” and that others, by “denying the Lord who bought them, bring upon themselves swift destruction.”
But pray, sir, when you tell us, “ The salvation of every soul giv en by the Father to the Son, in the eternal covenant of redemption, is as firmly secured as if those souls were already in glory,” do you not see the cloven foot on which your doctrine stalks along? Permit me to uncover it a moment, and strike my readers with salutary dread, by holding forth the inseparable counterpart of your dangerous opinion, ‘ Certain it is, that the damnation of every soul given by the Father to the devil, in the eternal covenant of reprobation, is as firmly secured as if those souls were already in hell.”” Shame on the man that first called such horrid tenets “ the doctrines of grace, and the free Gospel of Jesus Christ!” Confusion on the lying spirit, who broke out of the bottomless pit, thus to blaspheme the Father of mercies, delude good men, and sow the tares of Antinomianism! Q, sir, when you plead for such doctrines, instead of wielding aright “ the sword of the Spirit,” do you not plunge it in muddy, Stygian waters, till it is covered with sordid rust, and reeks with poisonous error? But you pursue:— VIII. Page 64. “To scruple the use of that expression, finished salyation, argues the greatest mistrust of the Mediator’s power, and easts the highest reflection upon his infinite wisdom, by supposing that he did not count the cost before he began to build, and therefore that either his own personal work, or that which he does in his members, (for they are only parts of the same salvation,) is left unfinished.” If we do not admit your doctrine, honoured sir, it is not because we mistrust the Mediator’s “ power,” and have low thoughts of his “ wisdom;” but because we cannot believe that he will use his power in opposition to his wisdom and truth, in taking the elect by main force into heaven, as a strong man takes a sack of corn into his granary; much less can we think that he will use his omnipotence in opposition to his mercy and justice, by placing millions of his creatures in such forcible circumstances, as absolutely necessitate them to sin and be damned, according to the horrible doctrine of finished damnation.
Nor do we suppose that Christ unwisely forgot to * count the cost.” No: from the beginning he knew that some would abuse their liberty, and bury their talent of good will, and gracious power to come unto him, “that they might have more abundant life.” But far from being disappointed, as we are when things fall out contrary to our fond expectation, he declared beforehand, “I have laboured in vain, yet surely my work is with my God,” Isa. xlix, 4. As if he had said, “ If I cannot rejoice over the obstinate neglecters of my great salvation; if my kindly dying for their sins, excepting that against the Holy Ghost, and my sincerely calling upon them to ‘ turn and live,’ Boe useless to them, through their ‘ doing despite to the Spirit of grace,’ and committing ‘ the sin unto death;’ yet my work will not be lost with respect to my God. For my impartial, redeeming love will effectually ‘stop every mouth,’ and abundantly secure the honour of all the Divine perfections, which would be dreadfully sullied, if, by an absolute decree that all should necessarily fall in Adam, and that millions should never have it in their power to rise by me, I had set my seal to the hormble doctrine of finished salvation.”
Here, then, in flourishing with your sword, you have “beaten the air,” instead of “ turning to flight the armies of”—those who are not clear in the doctrine of absolute predestination, whom you call— “aliens;” and in a quotation, p. 37, ‘absolutely place among the numerous hosts of the Diabolonians, who by the best of laws must die as election doubters.”
IX. Page 64. “If any thing be left unfinished, Christ would never have said, ‘ He that believeth hath everlasting life;’ it is already begun in his soul.” Well, if it is but begun, it is not yet finished. But you add, “ It is so certain in reversion, that nothing shall deprive him of it.” True, “if he continues in the faith and abides in Christ, hearing his voice and following him;” for who “shall pluck you out of the Redeemer’s hand?” ‘Who shall harm you, if ye be followers of that which is good?” But if the believer “makes shipwreck of his faith,” and ‘ends in the flesh,” after having “ begun in the Spirit,” with all apostates he shall “ of the flesh reap destruction.” Again:— “ Everlasting life,” in the passage you quote, undoubtedly signifies a title to eternal bliss, as it appears from these words of our Lord “He that has left brethren, &c, for my sake, shall receive im the world to come eternal life.” And from these words of St. Paul, Ye have your fruit unto holiness, and the end everlasting life.” Now if we give over following after holiness, and do not continue to leave all for Christ’s sake, may we not forfeit our title to glory, as the servant who had ten thousand talents forgiven him, forfeited his pardon and the privilege annexed to it, by “taking his fellow servant by the throat,” and arresting him for a “‘ hundred pence?” But supposing the expression ‘everlasting life,” means, as you intimate, “the life of God, already begun in the soul,” agreeably to these scriptures: “ The life that I live, I live by faith in the Son of God; for the just shall live by faith;” how can you infer that the life of faith is inamissible? If you can believe that every child quickened in the womb grows up to be a man, because he has human life in embryo, I will grant that no soul, quickened by the seed of grace, can miscarry, and that the seed of the word brings forth fruit to,maturity in every sort of ground.
Should you reply, * That the life of faith, or spiritual life, cannot be lost, because it is of an eternal nature,” I deny the consequence. Suppose I have lost an everlasting jewel, do I not quibble myself out of my invaluable property, if I say “I have not lost it, for it is everlasting?” Did not Satan and Adam lose their spiritual life? Do not all apostates lose it also? Is there a damned soul but what has lost it twice? Once in Adam, and the second time by his own per sonal transgressions? Are not all men who burn * in fire unquenchable trees plucked up by the roots;” not because they “died in Adam,” bu because they “are twice dead;” because they personally “ destroyea themselves,” and, when Christ gave them a degree of life, “* would not come to him that they might have it more abundantly?’ Thus, by resisting to the last the quickening beams of the Spirit that “strove with them,” they “quenched him” in themselves, and became apostates. If Christ is “the light and the life of men,” and if he “ enlightens every man that comes into the world,” are not all the damned apostates ¢ FOURTH CHECK TO ANTINOMIANISM. 255.
Have they not all fallen from some degree or other of quickening grace? Have they not all buried one or more talents? And is it not Satan’s masterpiece of policy, to make good men assure quickened sinners that they cannot lose their life, no, not by plunging: into the whirlpools of adultery, murder, and incest? The ancient serpent deceived our first parents by saying, “ Ye shall not surely die,” if ye eat of the forbidden fruit. But now, it seems, he may take his rest, for, O astonishing! Gospel ministers do his work; they inadvertently “ deceive the very elect,” and ‘ overthrow the faith of some,” by making them the very same false promise.
I have already observed, that he ‘ who believeth” is said to “ have everlasting life;” not only because, while he keeps the faith, he has a title to glory, but because living ‘ faith always works by love,” the grace that “never faileth,” the grace that ‘lives and abides for ever;” not indeed in this or that individual, during his state of probation, but in the kingdom of heaven, “‘ among the spirits of just men made perfect in love,” and confirmed in glory. However, you still urge, “'lo say that everlasting life can be lost, is a contradiction in terms: if it is everlasting, how can it be forfeited or lost?” How? Just as the Jews forfeited the land which God gave to Abraham for an everlasting possession, Gen. xvii,&. Just as the seed of Phinehas lost “ the everlasting priesthood,” Num. xxv, 13. Just as the Israelites “ broke the everlasting covenant,” Isaiah xxiv, 5. Just as Hymeneus and Philetus forfeited the everlasting privileges of believers; that is, by “making shipwreck of faith and a good conscience.” Here, then, the edge of your own sword is again blunted, and the stroke given to the “ aliens” easily parried with the unbroken “sword of the Spirit:” I mean the word of God illustrated by itself, and taken in connection with itself. However, you proceed:— X. Page 64. “ The chosen vessel, Paul, tells his beloved Timothy, that God ‘hath saved us, and called us with a holy calline,’” &c. Hence you conclude, that if we are elect, our salvation is finished. I grant, that God hath saved us from hell, placed us ina state of salvation begun, and “ called us with a holy calling, to work out our salya- tion with fear and trembling;” under some dispensation of that “ grace which was given us in Christ before the world began; according to God’s own purpose, that Christ should be the Saviour of all men, especially of them that believe.” But alas! though “ many are thus called, yet but few are chosen; because few walk worthy of their high vocation, few make their calling and election sure.” Numbers, like David and Solomon, Demas and Sapphira, believe for awhile, and “im time of temptation fall away;” some of whom, instead of rising again, “draw back unto perdition.”
Hence “the chosen vessel, Paul,” himself cries to halting believers, ‘¢ How shall we escape if we neglect so great salvation?” So far was ne from imagining that the salvation of some, and the damnation of others “were as firmly secured” as if the one were already in heaven, and the other in hell! So little did he think that to preach the Gospel was to present the elect with nothing but the cup of finished salvation, even when they take away the wives and lives of their neighbours; and to drench the reprobates with the cup of finished damnation, even while they ask, seek, knock, and endeavour to make their mock cailing sure! 7 Certain it is, that if the apostle spoke of your finished salvation, when he said, “ God hath saved us, and called us with a holy calling,” reprobated myriads may reasonably give over wrestling with almighty, ever- lasting wrath, and cry out, ‘“ He hath damned us, and called us with an unholy, hypocritical, and lying calling, according to his own purpose and wrath, which was given us in Adam before the world began.” O sir, by this frightful doctrine you give a desperate thrust to the hopes which millions entertain, that God is not yet absolutely merciless toward them, and that they may yet repent and be saved; but happily for them, it is with the dagger of error, and not with “the sword of the Spirit.”
XI. Page 65. “But farther. Believers are said to be ‘ saved by faith,’ and to be ‘kept by the power of God through faith unto salvation.’ Now true faith and salvation are here inseparably linked by the apostle.” Inseparably linked! Pray, sir, where is the inseparable link? I see it not. Nay, when I consult the apostles, on whose strained words you raise your argument, they rise with one consent against your doctrine. The one says, Some branches in Christ “* were broken off because of unbelief; thou standest by faith; [undoubtedly true faith;] nevertheless, fear, lest he also spare not thee. Behold his goodness toward thee, if thou continue in his goodness; otherwise thou also shalt be cut off.” The other declares, “ If after they [fallen believers, whom he does not call “ pleasant,” but cursed children | have escaped the pollutions of the world, through the knowledge of the Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ, (that is, through true faith,) they are again entangled therein, and overcome; the latter end is worse with them than the beginning, 2 Peter. ii, 20, compared with 2 Pet. i, 2, 8, 9, 10. Thus, sir, St. Paul and St. Peter, whom you eall to your assistance, agree to wrench your sword out of your own hand. But you soon take it up again.
XII. Page 64. “Christ being styled not only the author, but the finisher of our faith, he must be, consequently, the finisher of our salvation.” So he undoubtedly is, when we are “ workers together with him,” that is, when using the gracious talent of will and power, which he freely gives us, we “ work out our own salvation with fear and trembling.” But if we bury that talent, “do despite to the Spirit of grace, forget that we were washed from our sins,” and wallow again in the mire of iniquity; “‘ Christ,” the author of the faith which we destroy, ‘ profiteth us nothing; we are fallen from grace.”
Is it right to rock feeble believers in the cradle of carnal security, by telling them they can never lose the faith; when part of St. Paul’s triumphant song, just before he received the crown of martyrdom, was, “I have kept the faith?” What wonder was it that he should have kept, what even the carnal, incestuous Corinthian could never lose! When the Scriptures mention, not only those who “have kept the faith,” but those who “ have made shipwreck of it, and of a good conscience; those who “ believe for awhile, and in time of temptation fall away;” and those who one day believe, another day have little faith, and by and by have no faith;—are we not “wise above what is written,” and sow we not Antinomian tares, when we give lukewarm Laodiceans to understand they can never lose what, alas! they have already lost?
If Christ was to believe in his own blood for us, I grant, that the work of faith and salvation could not miscarry. But what ground have we to imagine that this is the case? Did the apostles charge Christ or sinners to believe under pain of damnation? If believing is entirely the work of Christ, why did he marvel at the unbelief of the Jews’? Did you ever marvel at the sessions that the constables in waiting did not act as magistrates? Did you ever send them to jail for not doing your work, as you suppose Christ sends unbelievers to hell for not believing, that is, upon your scheme, for not doing his work?
While we readily grant you, that the talent of faith, like that of industry, is the “free gift of God,” together with the time, opportunity, and power to use it; should you not grant us, that God treats us as rational, accountable creatures? That he does not use the gift of faith for us: that we may bury our talent of faith, and perish; as some bury their talent of industry and starve? And that it is as absurd to say, the faith of every individual in the Church is inadmissible, because Christ is the author and finisher of our faith, as to affirm that no individual ear of corn can be blasted, because Christ (who upholds all things by the word of his power) is the unchangeable author and finisher of all our harvests?
Once more, permit me, honoured sir, to hang the mill stone of rebrobation about the neck of your Diana, to cast her back with that cumbrous weight into the sea cf error, from whose scum she, like another Venus, had her unnatural origin. If the salvation of the elect is finished, because “ Christ is the author and finisher of their faith,” it necessarily follows, that the damnation of the reprobates is also finished, because ‘“‘ Christ is the author and finisher of their unbelief.” For he that abso-. lutely withholds faith, causes unbelief as effectually, as he that absolutely withholds the light, causes darkness.
If, in direct opposition to the words of our Lord, John iii, 18, you say, with some Calvinists, that ‘ Christ does not damn men for unbelief, but for their sins,” I reply, This is mere trifling. If Christ abso- lutely refuses them power to believe in the light of their dispensation, how can they but’sin? Does not Paul say, that “ without faith it is impossible to please God?” Is not unbelief at the root of every sin? Did not even Adam eat the. forbidden fruit through unbelief? And is not “ this our only victory, even our faith?”
An illustration will, I hope, expose the emptiness of the pleas which some urge in favour of unconditional reprobation, or, if you please, non-election. A mother conceives an unaccountable antipathy to her sucking child. She goes to the brink of a precipice, bends herself over it with the passive infant in her bosom, and, withdrawing her arms from under him, drops him upon the craggy side of a rock, and thus he rolls down from rock to rock, till he lies at the bottom beaten to pieces, a bloody instance of finished destruction. The judge asks the murderer what she has to say in her own defence. ‘The child was mine, replies she, and I have a right to do what I please with my own. Beside, I did neither throw him down nor murder him: I only withdrew my arms from under him, and he fell of his own accord. In mystic Geneva she is honourably acquitted; but in England the executioner is ordered to rid the earth of the cruel monster. So may God give us commission to rid the Church of your Diana, who teaches that he, the Father of mercies, does by millions of his passive children, what the barbarous mother did by one of hers; affirming, that he unconditionally withholds grace from them; and that, by absolutely refusing to be “ the author and finisher of their faith,” he is the absolute author and finisher of their unbelief, and consequently of their sin and damnation.
XIII. However, without being frightened at these dreadful consequences, you conclude as if you had won the day: p. 65, “* Now I appeal to any candid judges, whether I haye not brought sufficient authority from the best of authorities, God’s unerring word, for the use of that phrase, finished salvation,” which, p. 63, ‘in its full extent, I undertook to vindicate.” I cordially join in your appeal, honoured sir, and desire our unprejudiced readers to say, if you haye brought one solid proof from God’s unerring word in support of your fayourite scheme, which centres in the doctrine of finished salvation: and if that expression, when taken ‘in its full extent,” is not the stalking horse of every wild Nicolaitan ranter; and the dangerous bait, by which Satan, transformed into an angel of light, prevails upon unstable souls to swallow the silver hook of speculative, that he may draw them into all the depths of practical, Antinomianism.
XIV. I do not think it worth while to dwell upon the lines you quote from Mr. Charles Wesley’s hymns. He is yet alive to tell us what he meant by “It’s finished; it’s past,” &c. And he informs me that he meant ‘“ the sufficient sacrifice, oblation, and satisfaction, which Christ made upon the cross for the sins of the whole world, except ‘ doing despite to the Spirit of grace,’ or the sin against the Holy Ghost.” ‘The atonement, which is a considerable part of the Redeemer’s work, is undoubtedly finished; and if by a figure of poetry, that puts a part for the whole, you choose to give the name of finished salvation to a finished atonement, I have already observed, in the Third Check, that we will not dispute about the expression. We only entreat you so to explain and guard it, as not to give sanction to “ Antinomian dotages,” and charge the God of love with the blasphemy of finished damnation.
XV. The Calvinistical passage which you produce from the Christian Library is unguarded, and escaped Mr. Wesley’s or the printer’s attention. One sentence of it is worthy of a place in the Index Expurgatorius, which he designs to annex to that valuable collection. Ne- vertheless, two clauses of that very passage are not at all to your purpose. ‘Christ is now thoroughly furnished for the carrying on of this work: he is actually at work.” Now if Christ is actually at work, and carrying on his work, that work is not yet finished. ‘Thus, even the exceptionable passage which you, or the friends who gave you their assistance, have picked out of a work of fifty volumes, shows the absurdity of taking the expression, “finished salvation,” in its full extent.
Should you say, “ Christ is thoroughly furnished for his work, (namely, the salvation of the elect,) therefore that. work is as good as finished,” I once more present you with the frightful head of Geneva Medusa, and reply, “ Christ is thoroughly furnished for his work, (namely, the damnation of the reprobates,) therefore that work is as good as finished.” Thus all terminates still in uncovering the two iron-clay feet of your great image, absolute election and absolute reprobation, or, which is all one, finished salvation and finished damnation.
O sir, the more you fight for Dr. Crisp’s scheme of free grace, the more you expose his scheme of free wrath. I hope my judicious readers are shocked at it, as well as myself. Your “sword” really “ puts us to flight.” We start back,—we run away: but it is only from the depths of Satan, which you help us to discover in speculative Antinomianism, or barefaced Calvinism.
XVI. If you charge me with “ calumny,” for asserting that speculative Antinomianism and barefaced Calvinism are one and the same thing; to clear myself, I present you with the creed of an honest, consistent, plain-spoken Calvinist. Read it without prejudice, and say if it will not suit an abettor of speculative Antinomianism, and, upon occasion, a wild Ranter, wading through all the depths of practical Antino- mianism, as well as an admirer of “ the doctrines of grace.”
Five Letters, 1st edit. pp. 33, 34, 27. “I most firmly believe, that the grand cause of so much lifeless profession is owing to the sheep of Christ being fed in the barren pastures and muddled waters of a legalized Gospel. The doctrines of grace are not to be kept out of sight for fear men of corrupt minds should abuse them. I will no more be so fearful to trust God with his own truths, as to starve his children and my own soul: I will make an open confession of my faith.”
“1. I believe in God the Father Almighty, who from all eternity unconditionally predestinated me to life, and absolutely chose me to eternal salyation. Whom he once loved he will love for ever; I am therefore persuaded, (pp. 28, 31,) that as he didnot set his love on me at first for any thing in me, so that love, which is not at all dependent upon any thing in me, can never vary on account of my miscarriages: and for this reason; when I miscarry, suppose by adultery or murder, God ever considers me as one with his own Son, who has fulfilled all righteousness for me. And as he is ‘always well pleased’ with him, so with me, who am absolutely ‘bone of his bone and flesh of his flesh.’ (pp. 26,31.) There are no lengths, then, I may not run, nor any depths I may not fall into, without displeasing him; as I see in David, who, notwithstanding his repeated backslidings, did not lose the character of the man after God’s own heart. I may murder with him, worship Ashtaroth with Solomon, deny Christ with Peter, rob with Onesimus, and commit incest with the Corinthian, without forfeiting either the Divine favour or the kingdom of glory. ‘Who shall lay any thing to the charge of God’s elect?’ to the charge of a believer? to my charge? For, “2. (Pages 26, 27, 32.) I believe in Jesus Christ, that ‘by one offering has for ever perfected’ me, who am ‘ sanctified’ in all my sins: in him I am complete in all my iniquities. What is all sin before his atoning blood? Either he has fulfilled the whole law, and borne the curse, or he has not. If he has not, no soul can be saved; if he has, then all debts and claims against his people and me, be they more (suppose a thousand adulteries, and so many murders) or be they less, (suppose only one robbery,) be they small or be they great, be they before or be they after my conversion, are for ever and for ever cancelled. I set up no more mountainous distinctions of sin, especially sins after conversion. Whether I am dejected with Elijah under the juniper tree, or worshipping Milcom with Solomon; whether I mistake the voice of the Lord for that ofhis priest, as Samuel, or defile my neighbour’s bed, as David, I am equally accepted in the Beloved. For in Christ I am chosen, loved, called, and unconditionally preserved to the end. All trespasses are forgiven me. I am justified from all things. I already have everlasting life. Nay, I am now (virtually) set down in heavenly places with Christ; and as soon shall Satan pluck his crown from his head, as his purchase from his hand.”
Pages 27, 28. ‘ Yes, I avow it in the face of all the world; no falls or backslidings can ever bring me again under condemnation; for Christ hath made me free from the law of sin and death. Should | outsin Manasses himself, I should not be a less pleasant child; because God always views me in Christ, and in him I am without spot or wrinkle, or any such thing. Black in myself, I am still comely through the comeliness put upon me: and therefore He ‘who is of purer eyes than to behold iniquity,’ can, in the midst of all adulteries, murders, and incests, address me with, ‘ Thou art all fair, my love, my undefiled; there is no spot in thee!’ And,
- I believe in the Holy Ghost, the Spirit of grace, against whom I can never sin, (p. 26,) whose light and love I can never quench, to whom I can never do despite, and who, in his good time, will irresistibly and infallibly (Review, p. 38) work in me to will and to do. In the meantime I am perfectly secure ; for I can never perish, my salvation being already finished in the full extent of the expression.” (Review,
“Once, indeed, I supposed, that ‘the wrath of God came,’ at least for enormous crimes, ‘upon the children of disobedience;’ and I thought it would come upon me if I committed adultery and murder: but now I discover my mistake, and believe (p. 28 and 25) it is a capital error to confound me and my actions. While my murders, &ce, certainly displease God, my person stands always absolved, always complete, always pleasant in the everlasting righteousness of the Redeemer. I repeat it, (2d edit. p. 37,) it is a most pernicious error of the schoolmen, to distinguish sins according to the fact, and not according to the person. He that believeth hath as great sin as the unbeliever: nay, his sins, (p. 32,) for the matter of them are perhaps more heinous and scandalous than those of the unbeliever; but although he daily sinneth, perhaps as David and the Corinthian, by adultery, murder, and incest, he continueth godly. ‘Before I was acquainted with the truth, I imagined that sin would dishonour God and injure me: but since the preachers of finished salvation have opened my eyes, I see how greatly I was mistaken. And now I believe that God will overrule my sin, (whether it be adultery, murder, or incest,) for his glory and my good. “(1.) For his glory. (Pages 36, 30, 31, 32.) God often permits his own dearest children to commit adultery, murder, and incest, to bring about his purposes. He has always the same thing in view, namely, his own glory and my salvation, together with that of the other elect. This Adam was accomplishing when he put the whole world under the curse; Onesimus when he robbed Philemon his master; Judah when he committed incest with Tamar; and David when he committed adultery with Bathsheba. How has many a poor, faithless soul even blessed God for Peter’s denial! As for the incestuous Corinthian, the tenderness shown him after his crime, has raised many out of the mire, and caused them to recover their first love.
Ask about this work
Ask a question and Waymark will prioritize this work, with related primary sources where helpful.